Jul 08

A short simple end of financial year review

Sharemarkets both here and around the world showed solid performance over the last 12 months despite the lingering effects of the Global Financial Crisis in the form of sovereign debt concerns in Southern Europe.

The performance of Global Shares was 5.3%[1] in the year to 30 June 2010 although the last 3 months declined by 4.8% as concerns about the ability of the Greek government to pay its debts triggered a contagion effect on global sharemarkets. Given an insolvent government has never had a solvent banking system, and strong banks are required for economic growth, concerns around a “double dip recession” have surfaced around the world and held markets back in recent times.

For the unhedged Australian investor, the global sharemarket performance may have been better but the Australian dollar strengthened against most major currencies over 2009/10 thereby providing a slight drag on performance for unhedged global investors. The performance of Hedged Global Shares to the year ending June 2010 was therefore a much better 11.7%[2].

The Australian sharemarket had one of the better sharemarket performances around the world with a one year return to the end of June 2010 of 13.8%[3]. Most of this performance was achieved during the first quarter after which the market has largely moved sideways as local interest rates increased and the above-mentioned Euro-Sovereign debt concerns appeared.

The rising local interest rates put a mild dampener on local bond returns but they were still a reasonable 7.9%[4] for the year ending June 2010. The Reserve Bank increased interest rates from 3% at the start of the financial year to its current level of 4.5% and this resulted in a 3.9%[5] average cash return for the year ending June 2010. Whilst the Reserve Bank announced that they are more likely to increase than decrease the cash rate in the future, it is likely that the Euro-Sovereign Crisis will be the main determinant and therefore may stay on hold unless global economic data produces some extremely positive results.

The next 12 months will continue to present some challenging times for global financial markets as the above-mentioned debt issues are resolved. Australia continues to be the lucky country with a strong resource market continuing to sell its commodities to a fast growing China. Our residential property market continues to be buoyant and this is also a strong positive for our economic strength given its contribution to household wealth. Whilst these issues are positives, they also define the main risks to the Australian economy and our sharemarket strength. Whilst we anticipate further gains in sharemarket performance over the coming year, we also anticipate it will be a bumpy ride.


[1] MSCI World ex-Australia (Net Dividends) Index in $A

[2] MSCI World Index (AUD) Hedged

[3] ASX All Ordinaries Accumulation Index

[4] UBS Warburg Composite All Maturities Index

[5] UBS Warburg Bank Bill Index

Jul 06

Asset Class Performance for 2009-10

Overall it was a pretty good 12 months for all asset classes as they pretty much all achieved positive returns. Gold (USD) was the best with an annual return to the end of June 2010 of 34% whilst the only negative performer was the Australian Mercer Unlisted Property (pre-tax) index (looks like valuations finally caught up with them).

Despite the first six months of this calendar year producing around -10%, the Australian sharemarket finshed the financial year with 12 month performance of 13.8% (All Ords Acc Index). This was marginally better than the MSCI World Index (hedged) whcih returned 11.7% but not quite as good as the emerging markets, where the MSCI Emerging Markets Index returned 19.8% (despite China returning -1.8%).

For bond investors the year was a solid 7.9% for the Australian market (UBS Composite) and 10.0% for the global market (JP Morgan Broad WGBI ex-Aust index) and good old cash produced 3.89%.

With our solid economy and solid banking system our listed property market produced good returns and the ASX200 Property Trusts Accumulation Index had a 20.4% return…still a long way frion its 2007 high but I’m sure any long term listed property investor would be over the moon with that result.

Moving forward its a good bet that volatility will dominate the equity markets as deflation becomes a risk again in the developed markets keen on fiscal austerity. Removing stimulus before the end of an economic recovery is more likely to weaken the economy than provide growth. Either way, China’s growth will more important than ever to Australia and the rest of the world and if its GDP growth levels don’t look like hitting at least 8-9% then some more economic pain may be on the way for all.

Jul 06

Looks like interest rates might be flat for a while

 The latest yield curve of Australian Government Bonds shows interest rates staying around 4.5% for the next 3 years. This is a fairly obvious statement about our economy suggesting that growth is likely to be flat for a few years and inflation too is likely to be relatively unchanged. Of course, this view may will change but its the current market view of Australia.

Jun 30

Krugman says the depression has started

In the New York Times yesterday Paul Krugman’s Op-Ed piece suggested we are at the start of the world’s third depression thanks to fiscal tightening from Europe and the likely resultant deflation. I’m not going to do his article any more injustice so please have a read by clicking here…perhaps the stockmarkets of the world read this article over night also given the massive declines!

Jun 22

Structured Products – tough to get your money back

Source: Credit Suisse Global Investment Returns Yearbook 2010

The above chart shows the gross outperformance of Australian shares (including dividends) versus Australian Bonds and Bills. Over the 110 years to the end of 2009, shares provided an additional return of only 6% to 6.8% versus bonds and bills respectively.

Believe it or not, there is no other country in the world that has produced a greater equity risk premium over bonds and bills than Australia over the last 110 years…the contrarian investor is probably saying that its someone else’s turn but anyway, I digress…

…all I have to say is that given 5 to 12 year government bonds in this country are only yielding between 5% and 5.5% at the time of writing, it is an absolute disgrace that many structured products available to retail investors require the ASX 200 Accumulation Index to return double digits to cover the cost of funding!

Using this simple, but frequently used, measure for forecasting long term equity performance, if we assume the premium is likely to be 6% against bonds, then sharemarket returns will be around 11% to 11.5% over the next 5 or more years. With an expected dividend yield around 4%pa then the ASX200 Share Price Index performance will only be 7%pa…this is less than the cost of funding many of these appalling structured products (keep in mind structured products typically provide exposure to the ASX200 Share Price Index…not the accumulation index).

That’s my rant for the day.

Jun 22

Financial Crises for Dummies

Just found a great little article on the basic characteristics of financial crises by Rick Bookstaber…click here. It all seems so simple…before a crisis, Bookstaber says,

  • “Equities are rising
  • Volatility is low
  • Credit spreads are narrow
  • Correlations are low
  • The opportunities are in the hinterland of low liquidity
  • The yield curve is steep”

Its all true and appears so obvious. However when these market conditions appear good old emotion will stop us from getting on the Bookstaber train and it is the contrarian investor who will handle financial  crises the best. Unfortunately for the contrarian…they are more likley to be wrong for a long time…but at least there’s fewer tears in the long run and they will have least one “I told you so” per decade.

I encourage everyone to read the Bookstaber blog…there are some fasinating opinions there on many other issues…gold, municipal bond market, etc

Jun 22

A look at risks in pension portfolios

I know I haven’t been posting too much lately and I know with this post I am just repeating myself. My latest article for IFA magazine was published this week and for those who don’t subscribe and are interested in reading it…it can be found here.

More posts with some interesting analysis to follow!

May 28

A simple look at pension portfolio construction

An article that should appear in IFA magazine over the coming weeks the article can be found here. Basically, its a simple look at how traditional investment risks are exacerbated by the pension drawdown situation and it has a simple recommendation to combat these risks (timing, volatility, and high inflation)…yep…inflation linked annuities.

May 18

Short Economic Outlook for Newsletters

The economic recovery in Australia continues to be stronger than expected and is more aligned with our major Asian trading partners than other developed nations of the world. In its May 2010 Statement on Monetary Policy, the Reserve Bank forecast the Australian economy to expand around 3.25% over 2010 with increased growth during 2011 of 3.75% to 4%. These growth forecasts are significantly higher than the 2% to 2.5% growth forecasts that were made 12 months ago hence showing how much our economy has truly improved.

Some of the recent statistical releases supporting the strength of our economy include declining unemployment levels (5.3% – April 2010*); strong growth in housing prices (20% growth in year to March 2010* ); and inflation data at the upper end of the Reserve Bank’s targeted range (2.9% April 2010*). Further boosts for the Australian economy have come from continued strong commodity prices combined with a strong Chinese economy which, if it continues, augurs very well for our longer term prosperity.

Despite our relative economic strength, financial markets have resumed their turbulence thanks to increased risks of the Greek government failing to paying its debts. Greece, along with Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Ireland, borrowed heavily during the Global Financial Crisis in an attempt to rescue their failing economies and as they all have the Euro as their currency, it appears deflating their local prices and wage reduction is the only way these countries can be competitive again. Unfortunately, this typically results in stagnant economies and, for government, continued lower levels of revenue to pay their debts.

If China and our local property prices continue their phenomenal growth then local interest rates may resume their upward trend, however, the Euro crisis and its associated risks may deter the Reserve Bank from raising interest rates in the short term and should remain at 4.5%. Global sharemarkets, including our own, are expected to be volatile over the coming weeks/months whilst specifics of the $1trillion rescue package for Greece et al. and their capacity to meet their debt obligations unfolds.

*Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics

Apr 30

Euro Problem

The Euro member countries with the highest levels of debt (Greece, Portugal, and Spain) have another problem that restricts their ability to fight their current economic enemies…the Euro.

Before the crisis, these countries experienced significant investment and a property boom resulting in strong economies and inflation that was higher than the other Euro member countries.

When the property bubble burst each government did what they had to do to rescue their ailing economies and borrowed funds to invest and take the place of the near-collapsed banking system. Unfortunately because they experienced higher inflation before the crisis, investment into these countries was less attractive than others during the crisis, and because of their attachment to the Euro, deflating their currency was never going to occur at the level required to aid recovery.

With Spain’s unemployment over 20%, and Portugal and Greece’s increasing to around 10%, paying out unemployment benefits is not getting any cheaper and thanks to the Euro, these countries not being an attractive place to invest will continue to place significant concern on their ability to repay their debt.

To be competitive again the only thing left for these countries may be years of painful deflation. Unfortunately, this also means many years of economic struggle but unfortunately is no respite for their debt problems.

Older posts «

» Newer posts