Aug 05

Advice about Advisers from the Reformed Broker

I love following other’s blogs and the Reformed Broker is one of them. At the time of writing his latest post provides some “free advice to the Hollywood set when working with an adviser” and I lay these points out for you below (I hope he doesn’t mind but please check out his blog…its excellent reading)…

1.  Anyone who refers to himself as a “Financier” is full of sh*t.

2.  Your financial advisor is not supposed to play polo or wear designer sunglasses, nor should he ever have a popped up collar under any circumstances.  He must never wear shoes without socks or wear a watch with a diamond bezel.

3.  In truth, if an advisor or money manager’s opening shpiel is about all of the other famous people he works with, this should not make you feel comfortable.  Its actually a giant red flag indicating that you are dealing with a starf*&%er and a social climber who is more concerned with himself than you.

4.  Even your brother-in-law will rob you if you give up power of attorney.  Go ask Billy Joel.  Uma Thurman signed over Power of Attorney so that Ken Starr would do her taxes.  That’s funny, my CPA never seemed to need signatory authority over my bank account to prepare my tax forms…hmmm.

5.  Custody of assets is all you need to know.  If your money guy needs to set up extraneous accounts in both your name and his, its a scam.  If he asks you to transfer money into a financial institution that you haven’t seen advertise during The Masters, its a scam.  If he tells you not to worry about receiving statements because he’s “taking care of everything”, its a scam.  You get the idea.

6.  Most important:  Your financial guy is NOT supposed to party with you.  He shouldn’t be at the same nightclub as you buying bottles, nor should he have a copy of Variety in his waiting area.  The financial advisor is the guy you apologize to when you sleep through an appointment with him, hung over from an all-night rager.  He’s not supposed to be there with you at the club, holding your hair while you vomit up Veuve Cliquot and Red Bull.

7.  Almost forgot, young stars and starlets… if the advisor has a nicer home than you or your initial consultation takes place on his yacht – run, Forrest, run

All very true!

Aug 04

RBA Rates stay on hold – may stay that way for a while

The current setting of monetary policy is resulting in interest rates to borrowers around their average levels of the past decade. With growth likely to be close to trend, inflation close to target and the global outlook remaining somewhat uncertain, the Board judged this setting of monetary policy to be appropriate.

This was the final paragraph of Glenn Stevens’ statement on the RBA’s Monetary Policy Decision. Each of the justifying characteristics in this statement suggest a situation that may stay the same for a little while. Earlier parts of his statement include…

“…the Bank expects global growth to be about trend over the coming year.”

“…output growth in Australia over the year ahead is likely to be about trend”

“Credit outstanding for housing has continued to expand, but the upward pressure on dwelling prices appears to have abated”

“Through to mid 2011, underlying inflation is likely to be in the top half of the target zone, while CPI inflation will probably be just above 3 per cent for a few quarters due to the impact of the tax changes and increases in utilities prices.”

So it appears the RBA is predicting most of their important measures are to be around “trend” or within target over the coming year. Only government costs, such as higher taxes on tobacco and higher utility costs, will contribute to overall inflation being a little high, but overall everything is pretty much in line. Throw in concerns about the major global economies, which aren’t going away any time soon, and interest rates should stay on hold for a littel while yet.

So what does the market think? The chart of government bond yields is below…pretty flat for many years…so the market agrees…no rate rises for a while yet.

 

Aug 02

Structure Product Review – Instreet Link Series XIX and XXI

Basic characteristics of these 2 structured products are…

  • They provide the investor with exposure to the S&P/ASX200 Share Price Index (ie no exposure to dividends)
  • They each have capped performance (Indicative caps are 28.5% for Series XIX and 47% for Series XXI)
  • The terms are 2 years for Series XIX and 3 years for Series XXI commencing 30 September 2010
  • The indicative Issue price is $1.49 per $10 unit of XIX and $2.35 per $10 unit of XXI
  • The return is a basket of 5 ASX listed stocks as it is a deferred purchase agreement (DPA) structure
  • Liquidity is quarterly or at the discretion of InStreet

Purchasing this investment (or should I say, “Derivative” or even “exotic Call Option”), is identical to…

  • Purchasing an “At The Money” call option on the S&P/ASX200 Share price index, PLUS
  • Writing (or selling) an “Out of the Money” call option on the S&P/ASX200 Share price index where the strike price is $12.80 for series XIX and $14.70 for series XXI
  • The terms of each call option contract is as per above characteristics, i.e. 2 years for Series XIX and 3 years for series XXI

Like purchasing any call option, exotic or otherwise, if the price performance of the underlying asset, ie. the S&P/ASX200, is less than zero at expiry, then the value of the investment is zero and all moneys are lost. So massive downside risk for this investment. 

So are these two products priced appropriately?

Series XIX

If we purchase an at the money call option in the market and at the same time sell a call option with a strike price at 28.5% out of the money, then using Black & Scholes option pricing means the net cost (excluding brokerage) is probably at most $1.10 per unit…this assumes an interest rate of anywhere between 5% and 6% and that volatility is the same for both call options…this means that because the investor is paying an indicative $1.49, being conservative, they are paying a premium of 35% (39cents/$1.10)…or 35% brokerage on the option contracts!

Series XXI

Using the same assumptions as series XIX except the call option sold has a strike price of $14.70 and the term is 3 years means the net cost (excluding brokerage) is probably at most $1.70…given the indicative cost is $2.35, we again have a hefty premium (or brokerage) of 38% (65 cents/$1.70).

Given 35 cents per transaction goes to adviser (20 cents or 2% of $10) and arranger (15 cents or 1.5% of $10), clearly this a product where the big winner is adviser and arranger (i.e. Instreet Investment Ltd) and someone else (I guess the options broker).

This demonstrates the massive margins that can occur within structured products and guess what…none of the pricing that I have shown above is disclosed….both adviser and investor is left ot ehir own resources to determine whether this investment is a good deal or not. So, the question is….given the Black & Scholes pricing used, do you think a 35% plus brokerage is worth paying for a capped call option position?

Aug 02

A Need for Style Indices and/or more Style Biased Passive Funds

According to Morningstar, the best performing Australian equities fund over the last 10 years is the Dimensional Australia Value Trust. In this competition of winners, where only the biggest or best have survived, the Dimensional fund has outperformed 44 other funds, including those value giants, Perpetual, Tyndall and Investors Mutual and and different styled behemoths like  BT, and Colonial First State. Now Dimensional’s 5 year performance isn’t quite as flash as it ranks only 22nd out of 79 funds but that’s still not bad.

The thing about Dimensional is that its a low cost passive fund whose underlying stocks are arranged to produce a “value” bias in the way the academic gurus, Fama and French, designed many years ago…much of which is in the public domain…i.e. a bias towards low Price/Book stocks. So there is no claim for rocket science and, to a degree, could be fairly easily replicated.

Anyway, well done Dimensional…but…the real issue is, that if a passive style biased fund is number one after an incredible tricky decade that include the tech wreck and the GFC, then active managers have seriously failed. Most of the Australian fund managers are continually compared to the broad market cap weight ASX200 or ASX300 accumulation indices whether they have a style bias or not. Fund managers, like Investors Mutual, Perpetual, and Tyndall, always show their long term results and how they’ve outperformed these market cap weighted indicies but because of their style bias they should be compared to an index that is more reflective of the way they invest money. So if that style is in or out of favour compared to the broader market then their perforamcne can be judged for its true active worth. The same goes for Growth etc.

Twenty years ago, Fama and French showed there is a risk adjusted premium paid for Small Cap and Value stocks over the longer term and for the unsuspecting public (or super trustee etc) to better assess the added value of an actively managed fund its time we had some style biased indices that are a little more publicly available alongside of more style biased passive funds to invest in…particularly for when we (or Jeremy Cooper or his replacement) work out that active alpha does not frequently persist over time or more importantly…with larger inflow.

Jul 30

Knock me over with a feather – house prices decline

The RP Data/Rismark house price index has shown the first monthly decline in house prices in 17 months and largest since April 2008!!! …well…its down seasonally adjusted…house prices actually still went up. With global asset allocation gurus like Jeremy Grantham (one of the fundies I do listen to) and vocal locals like Steve Kean suggesting the Australian residential housing market is in a bubble, I guess it was just a matter of time.

Jeremy Grantham, of GMO, believes both Australian and UK house prices are completely out of kilter with household income, and as a recently divorced current renter who is looking at houses with the view of ideally owning a (small) mortgage, I have to agree that the prospect of buying a house in Australia (ok, in Brisbane…well…say…not too far out of Brisbane CBD) is downright scary. Now I get the undersupply issue in Australia, but with households stretched so much to buy, with credit being tougher to get, and with rents so low (I pay a rental yield of around 2% to 2.5%) that investors must be edgy, at some stage growth must slow or go backwards…lets face it, everything is cyclical. Grantham says that if the Austrailan and UK house bubbles don’t correct it would be the first time in history that a bubble has not burst…so….is the latest monthly downturn the beginning of the end? Maybe if there’s an external shock to the local (or maybe global) economy.

Jul 30

Australian Government Bond Yield Curve update

I haven’t looked at the government bond yield curve for a while so here it is. I’m sure you don’t need the chart to know that the economic outlook was looking much better back in March and April, then it has since (i.e. the curve was sloping upwards much steeper back then). With bond yields below 5% for maturities out to, say, 6 years, the market does not appear to hold any strong views of strong inflation and therefore any strong likelihood of interest rate rises. With double dip recession and deflation talk in the US, China’s rate of economic growth slowing down, and Europe continuing its talk of being fiscally austere, its no wonder the local economic outlook isn’t as bullish as the newspapers suggest.

Jul 28

Robert Shiller expects a double dip recession in the US

I returned home this afternoon from a conference and turned on the new 24hour news channel, ABC24, and was listening to a couple of Australian finance experts say how positive they are about the US Economy. The ABC interviewer said Robert Shiller (Yale Professor of Economics and early predictor of both the tech crash and US home price crash) said there was a 50-50 chance of a double dip recession after which they both strogly disagreed. Anyway, I digress, I actually just read the Robert Shiller comments and he actually said,

For me a double-dip is another recession before we’ve healed from this recession … The probability of that kind of double-dip is more than 50 percent.  I actually expect it.

There are in fact many many US academics who are expecting a double dip recession and they are largely putting it down some or all of the folloiwng reasons (courtesy www.caclulatedriskblog.com) …

  • Less federal spending this half
  • End of the inventory rebuild
  • Continued household deleveraging
  • Another downturn in housing
  • Slowdown in China and Europe
  • Cutbacks at both State and Local level

Now the Australian fund managers may be right and the US may not enter recession again and perhaps I’m reading the wrong material, but I have to admit that it is very rare that I hear Australian fund managers talk of anything but bullish markets and economies…I’m afraid their conflicts of interest on these macro issues have lead me to no longer listen to a word they say.



Jul 20

More inaccurate analysts

This chart comes from the McKinsey Quarterly from back in April 2010 and shows how inaccurate equity analysts have been when predicting Earnings for S&P500 companies over the last 25 years….basically far too bullish and no where near accurate. So just like the last post, the key learning is to not take too much notice as to what  analysts predict when it comes to the stockmarket as they are pretty much guaranteed to be wrong.

The biggest concern to come out of this chart is that they may be more prone to overestimation….might relate to their remuneration incentives…I don’t really know…just saying

Jul 20

Great to know these guys are paid a fortune

Strategists June 2011 forecasts for the S&P/ASX 200
Deutsche Bank 6250
UBS 5800
Citigroup 5500
Goldman Sachs 5375
Macquarie 5068
JP Morgan 5000
Morgan Stanley 5027*
Credit Suisse 5000*
Merrill Lynch 4500*
Average 5302 points

Source: AFR 1 July 2010.

*December 2010 forecasts – no June 11 forecasts provided

With such variance amongst the so-called leading strategists in this country, I’m sure you can throw the proverbial dart at the dartboard and have just as good a chance as picking where the ASX200 will be in the next 12 months. Oh well, I’m sure they all sound impressive when they explain how they come to their guaranteed incorrect estimate!

Jul 20

Latest Article for Publication – Guaranteeing Investment Success

I have just submitted an article, on behalf of my employer, to the Australian version of the Journal of Financial Advice. Its a fairly simple message….advisers could better look after their client’s financial needs and goals by increasing their focus on their client’s cash flow needs as opposed to the focus on investment strategy. I know investment strategy is the sexy part….both for adviser and client…but increasing a client’s ability to save will quite often result in a much higher balance and retirement lifestyle then chasing investment returns risk.

Anyway, for anyone interested my draft version can be found by clicking Guaranteeing Investment Success – July 2010.

Older posts «

» Newer posts