Apr 30

Greek Impact

Potential Consequences of a Greek Default

Whilst Greece is only a small part of the EU economy (it accounts for less than 2% in combined GDP of the sixteen EU member states) the potential default on its sovereign debt may have significantly greater ramifications…

  • The largest holders of Greek Sovereign debt are the Greek banks. There has never been a time when an insolvent country has had solvent banks. It would be expected that the Greek banks will experience balance sheet losses resulting in a strong likelihood of a ‘run’ on the banks and their ultimate insolvency.
  • As at September 2009, the Greek government had raised around $272B from other European banks. A default would result in potential significant losses on these bank’s balance sheets. The primary inter-bank relationships with the Swiss ($78.6), French ($78.9B) and German ($43.2B) banks. This may also result in more “bank runs” and insolvency concerns…more bailouts???
  • There is the risk of a contagion effect that may flow onto other governments and banks resulting in a spike in yields and potential liquidity crisis. Other governments at most risk include Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Ireland who all have significant levels of debt. Both Portugal and Spain have recently received credit rating downgrades by Standard and Poors.
  • This type of contagion effect could very well flow into another global credit crisis resulting in another slowdown in the global economy. Government bailouts a second time around surely would not be possible.

 

Apr 16

Is it over for Agribusiness MIS?

Without a doubt, this has been the worst investment sector I have ever seen. Apart from the overall dismal performance track record of this sector, a few years ago now we had the disaster of Saxby Bridge and their agri-boiler room sales tactics, and in the last 12 months we’ve had the collapse of Timbercorp, Great Southern and two days ago Forest Enterprises Australia (FEA).

Throw in that the biggest pusher of agr-MIS projects, Professional Investment Services (PIS), have withdrawn all agri projects from their APL thus placing enormouse sales pressure on the sector and its difficult to see what future exists.

I’m sure the government is dissatisfied with the lack of success and there would also have to be enormous legislative risk to this sector…for mine…obviously…agri-MIS is a tax effective way of losing money and a complete revamp of the sector is needed before this sector is worthy of anyone’s investment again!

Mar 25

APRA Releases June 09 Super Performance

APRA yesterday released their June 2009 performance analysis of super funds and no surprises to see the Industry Super Fund MTAA at the bottom of the pile. with a return of -23.3%. MTAA was the previous number one fund over numerous years but with significant exposure to unlisted asset classes of private equity, property, and infrastructure its true risk has finally surfaced.

Unfortunately liquidity risk is often the forgotten risk and over the last few year many investors have suffered immensely because of it. MTAA achieved very high returns over a long period of time and unfortunately most observers attributed that high performance to skill. Wrong. The reason for their high performance is that they took on high risk and a substantial part of that high risk came in the form of illiquidity and over the 2008-09 financial year MTAA’s risky investment strategy was exposed.

I’m sure I sound like a broken record but the cliche lives on… noone receives high returns without accepting high risk. Understanding which risks you are prepared to accept and have accepted are two of the most important questions to answer in the investment decision.

To see the APRA report please click here.

Mar 21

Asset bubbles

There has been a lot of talk about asset bubbles around the world despite the Global Financial Crisis still being with us. I thought I’d provide a list off the top of my head and perhaps this represents a list of where most downside investment risk resides…

  • Australian Residential Property…see Business Spectator article here
  • Gold…see Bookstaber’s blog here
  • Sovereign debt (European, Japanese, and US)…just read any newspaper
  • China (Shares and Property)
  • Emerging Markets

With private sector credit drying throughout the world and being replaced with public debt there is little surprise that sovereign debt is of concern. For those who are investing, clearly the funds are flowing into emerging markets, whose emergence from the GFC was significantly faster than the developed world. And, of course, Australia does what Australia does…invest in residential property…interesting article from Steve Kean in Business Spectator on Tuesday (click here)…although he overlooks the supply issues a little.

Anyway, to paraphrase Keynes, markets can stay irrational longer than most can say solvent, so we don’t know what’s next but keep a close eye on these asset classes.

Mar 21

My 5 Minute Economic Update

Whilst many have declared the global financial crisis over, lingering side effects are still prevalent in numerous forms throughout the world. The financial crisis started as a credit crisis amongst the banks but has now moved to credit concerns amongst some of the governments of the world. Recent financial news has centred on the debt problems of Greece, however there are broader debt concerns across Europe and it is focused on a group of countries with an unfortunate acronym, PIGS, Portugal, Ireland, Greece (stil), and Spain. Germany and France have indicated they will not let Greece fall, but for each of the PIGS there are still government debt problems to sort out but with an unfortunate solution. Simplistically, because they all have the same currency, the Euro, they cannot easily attract foreign investment due to an inability to depreciate this shared currency. Unfortunately for the PIGS, they may be looking at years of price deflation to become competitive again and this will most likely result in continued recession.

In the US, the central bank has continued to leave their cash rates close to zero percent indicating strong economic growth is still some way off and this is supported by mixed economic data shows little direction for the economy. Unemployment remains close to 10% and with talk of Obama winding down some of the stimulus measures; it is difficult to see where US economic growth will be coming from.

On the positive side, the Australian economy continues its forward march and the December quarter’s economic growth figures indicated growth at around 0.60%. Unemployment continues to drop and is currently at 5.3%. These positive results along with a buoyant property market and continued strength of one of Australia’s largest trading partners, China, also resulted in another increase to the Cash Rate to 4% on March 2. The Reserve Bank continued to warn there may be more increases to come.

After some poor sharemarket performance in January, primarily due to the Greek debt concerns, local sharemarkets provided a positive return of 2.2% for the month of February. Global sharemarkets were mixed with February returns being positive in both the US (+2.9%) and UK (+3.2%) and negative in wider Europe (-1.7%) and Japan (-0.7%).

Moving forward, the likely growth drivers of the Australian economy will continue to come from China, and the primary risks will relate to the sovereign debt issues of Europe, rising interest rates locally, and unwinding existing fiscal stimulus too quickly. Unfortunately the song remains the same and whilst the worst of the global financial crisis may be behind us, numerous significant risks remain.

Mar 01

Reuters Poll – Westpac disagrees with itself

Fascinating that St George and Westpac, supposedly the same company now, have differing opinions on what the RBA is going to do tomorrow. Clearly, there’s no economic department merger yet!

Mar 01

Reuter’s Poll for tomorrow’s RBA Meeting

Reuters Consensus / Forecasts

Economist  –  RBA Rate ( % )       
AMP –  4.00     
ANZ  –  4.00     
Barclays  –  4.00     
Citi  –  3.75     
CBA  –  4.00     
Deutsche  –  3.75     
4Cast  –  4.00     
GSJBW  –  4.00     
ICAP  –  4.00     
JP Morgan  –  3.75     
Macquarie  –  4.00     
NAB  –  3.75      
Nomura  –  3.75     
RBS  –  4.00     
St George  –  3.75     
TDSec  –  4.00     
UBS  –  4.00     
Westpac  –  4.00     
———-    —–     
Low  –  3.75     
High  –  4.00     
Average  –  4.00     
Median  –  4.00     
———-    —–     
        

Feb 19

Back to Basics Portfolio Construction

My latest draft article submitted for publication in IFA can be found here. In an nutshell, one of the problems with asset allocation portfolio construction in recent years is the increase in the number of asset classes promising diversification benefits…hasn’t quite turned out that way. Secondly, we’ve seen equity-like risk creeping into the fixed interest and even cash asset classes which have created a few problems in recent times. Thirdly, dealing with rising inflation in retail investment portfolios has traditionally been dealt with via an equities exposure…this is prone to failure as equities can be a very poor hedge to inflation…inflation linked bonds and real assets (not stapled property securities) have proven to be the best inflation hedge.

Understanding total portfolio risks is essential to good portfolio construction and knowing how much market risk (including the possibly hidden equity-like risks) and liquidity risks to name a couple will remove more of the hidden surprises while all markets continue to be volatile.

Feb 01

A Simple Portfolio Analysis of the Future Fund

On Friday the Future Fund published its asset allocation as at 31 December 2009. Before we jump to any conclusions about its make-up its important to understand what the investment objectives are…

CPI plus 4.5% to 5.5%pa over a rolling ten year period with an acceptance of short term underperformance whilst the Strategic Asset Allocation is being developed

The asset allocation of the future fund as at 31 December 2009 is…

  • Australian Shares – 12.7%
  • Global Shares (developed) – 24.0%
  • Global Shares (emerging) – 3.6%
  • Private Equity – 2.3%
  • Property – 2.9%
  • Infrastructure – 2.4%
  • Debt Securities – 25.4%
  • Alternative Assets – 11.4%
  • Cash – 15.5%
  • plus Telstra

One can only assume that given the return benchmark, the allocation to cash will continue to diminish (it went from 32% to 15% in one quarter) and the ultimate fund will be relatively aggressive. What any investor can learn from this current asset allocation is the level of diversification across asset class…certainly high.

Feb 01

RBA Rate Rise tomorrow? Odds on

Australian Government Bond Yields – 29 Jan 2010

Source: Bloomberg
The RBA Cash rate is currently at 3.75% and with government backed 30 day bank bills at 4.12% and the recent tender of 23 March 2010 Treasury Notes fetching a yield of ~3.96% the financial markets are pretty much expecting a 25bps increase.
Whilst the sharemarkets have had the jitters whereby the ASX200 has dropped in excess of 6% this year, it is only government bond with a maturity greater than 1 year whose yields have dropped. The shorter term rates haven’t dropped much at all as the market continue to believe that 2010 will be a year of rising RBA rates.
As for the chart above…it doesn’t really reflect too much of what I’ve said and actually contradicts the 3 month rates I quoted earlier…my only comment is…what’s going on with Bloomberg such that it quotes 3 month Treasury Notes at 3.75%??? Might be best to double check rates from different sources before accepting them.

Older posts «

» Newer posts