Sep 27

Slight rise for Australian Government Bonds over last 2 weeks

Source: Bloomberg, RBA

The above chart uses price from this morning for the 28 September data and as it shows there has only been a slight improvement in the yield curve over the last couple of weeks so really  no significant impact on troubled beliefs at this point in time. Overnight the equity markets were very strong, particularly in Europe, but there is no strong evidence of any Euro-debt resolutions and the market rally is currently one based on ‘hope’. Volatility will continue.

Sep 26

Sensational Bearish Interview

Found this via Zero Hedge …sensational interview on the BBC with a trader who believes “Goldman Sachs rules the world” and that “this economic crisis is like a cancer, if you just wait and wait thinking this  is going  to go away, just like a cancer its going to grow and its gong to be too late”…the BBC interviewers were flabbergasted

Sep 25

Reducing Equity Risk with Bonds

Earlier in the week I was at a meeting whereby one of the attendees suggested that in a balanced portfolio (~70% equities) the equities proportion adds around 90% of the risk, and then in yesterday’s Australian Financial Review I see a headline quote from Stephen Nash (FIIG Securities) that said, “If investors replaced half their equity portfolio with long bonds, they could cut their risk by half and cut the return by about 1 per cent” .

Over the last 100 years or so, equities have outperformed bonds and bills by around 4%pa around the world so whilst I’m unsure a loss of 1% in return potential is a reasonable assumption these comments certainly got me thinking about what has actually happened with regards to equities versus bonds in terms of risk.

Source: Index data originally sourced from Morningstar via van Eyk

The above tables shows some analysis I did for both local and global equities and bonds over the last 21 years or so. I also combined the returns to produce a 50% allocation each to bonds and equities as per Stephen Nash’s suggestion.

These results who that, certainly over the last 20 years, declining interest rates around the world certainly resulted in much better returns versus equities on a risk adjusted basis (sharpe ratio) than equities and therefore resulted in a significant risk reduction of the 50/50 portfolio. Maximum drawdowns for the 50/50 portfolios more than halved over the last 10 and 20 years and this significant risk reduction was also evident when looking at theoretical Value at Risk (calculated using historic return and risk figures) or the actual 5th percentile of returns.

The time period where Stephen Nash’s comment didn’t quite ring true was in the 1990s when Global shares were the strong performer and the “Risk” reduction of the 50/50 portfolio didn’t quite make it to half. However the risk reduction was still significantly reduced (and more than halved) when looking at Sharpe ratio, theoretical value at risk, or the actual 5th percentile of returns.

This overly simplistic analysis does suggest that replacing half an equities portfolio with bonds may significantly reduce risk in terms of volatility or in terms of downside risk. However, what we face today are bonds that are yielding around no more than 4%pa across all maturities (and I am talking government bonds, not credit). So unlike the last 20 years where yields have decreased (5 years government bonds decrease from more than 10% in 1995 to around 3.6% today…RBA data I looked at only went back to 1995), the risk to bonds in the long term is  increasing yields which means downside risk is far greater than we have seen for some time.

What is in favour of bonds is the enormous volatility equity markets so I tend to agree with Stephen Nash that bonds will half the short term risk of the equities portfolio but I do have fears for the long term risk of such a strategy.

Sep 22

Europe equity markets getting smashed…

…and US futures not looking much better.

The Euro Stoxx 50 is down 4.4% at the time of writing; UK, German, French, and Spanish equity markets are all down more than 4.3%. The S&P500 futures are down around 1.5% and Australia’s SPI200 is also down around 1%.

Plenty of downside risk yet whilst politicians kick the Greek can down the road and US politicians continue to put their own aspirations first and the US economy second. Unfortunately for Australians, the Chinese Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) showed continued weakness such that most manfacturers believe the business outlook is getting worse.

No doubt all of this market carnage will continue to fuel the newspapers and television over the coming days and weeks so I can only see confidence deteriorating everywhere.  There appears little sign of what could turn around this deteriorating global situation amongst the major economies and markets…perhaps a Greek default???…that certainly might accelerate a turnaround but I don’t think anyone knows how much worse things would get first.

Sep 21

Tonight should be a turning point…either way

With the Federal Open Mark Committee (FOMC) currently meeting, many pundits are expecting a very very big package to be announced by Ben Bernanke tomorrow. If its not what the market expects, then I imagine there’ll be more equity market pain but if it is big, then I’m confident we’ll see a strong market (so a purchase of both put and call option appears to be an appropriate strategy).

Given Obama has little to no chance of getting anything decent through the Republican controlled congress, inflation is a non-issue, Ben has the freedom to try something innovative and big and he appears to be the only US option left. In terms of being innovative…could be another QE3 at the long end of the yield curve or even a concentrated monetary expansion where he buys bonds of a specific non-government securities.

Either way, I still believe the European debacle is the biggest issue and it will have no impact on solving that.

Sep 20

What returns should bonds provide over the next 5 years?

This is one of the most frequent questions I am asked by advisers and my usual answer is, “well, the yield of Australin bonds is around x% so that’s pretty much what you should expect to receive”. I’ve pretty much accepted that my answer is roughly correct but never really tested its accuracy..until now!

Source: RBA, Morningstar

The above chart shows the 5 Year Australian Government Bond yield from the start of 1995 to August 2006 (red line), and the 5 year forward return of the UBS Composite index from each date (blue line). So the last blue data point at 31 August 2006 is in the annualised return of the UBS Composite index from 31 August 2006 to 31 August 2011. As the chart shows, the correlation is quite strong and the 5 year Australian bond curve does in fact appear to be a reasonable estimate of the bond market return.

The actual difference between he 2 lines is around 50bps. To make sense of this difference there’s two obvious reasons. Firstly, the UBS Composite index contains a little over 20% invested in less than AAA-rated securities so you would expect a return premium due to this (assuming the credit risk more than compensates the defaults). Secondly, the duration (and average maturity) of the index is different to a 5 year bond so this would also create a difference…although I thought the index was lower so I would expect the longer duration bond to provide a higher return in a time period of declining yields.

Anyway, for a 5 year period the bond yield does appear to be a reasonable proxy for future returns on the bond market. As at today, 5 year bonds are yielding around 3.75% so it looks like an investment in a diversified portfolio of investment grade bonds should provide not much over 4%pa over the next 5 years.

Sep 16

Australian Government Bond Yield Curve…still dropping

Source: Reserve Bank of Australia

I’ve just updated my last yield curve from just over two weeks ago and as the above chart shows yields have dropped another ~40bps since then. This is an indication of the lack of global stability driven out of Europe and US and a resolution to their issues is clearly a long way away. That doesn’t mean markets will necessarily continue to drop but it is difficult to see any catalyst that will create a sustained market rally.

This curve suggests a very strong chance of an interest rate drop from the RBA is not too far away and according to the ASX Interest Rate Tracker, latest figures suggest a 57% chance of a 25bps drop next month. Whilst I would like to see a rate drop (would certainly help my mortgage payments), and despite reports that CPI figures were downgraded (the ABS announced yesterday that they weren’t), I’m not so sure it is going to happen. The Reserve Bank takes a 3 year view on inflation and last week’s announcement that Terms of Trade figures were up in the June quarter may influence their higher inflation outlook, so I believe the RBA will keep rates steady. The one issue that may change this will be a European-driven banking crisis that freezes the inter-bank market…there already is a banking crisis (all sovereign crises are banking crises), but there are potential signs of credit issues (a few French bank insiders are talking about their own bank’s struggles), but hopefully the ECB et al can ensure it doesn’t happen.

Sep 15

Hedge Funds and Banks straining

Last night UBS lost $2billion due to another “rogue” doing unauthorised trades and as reported last night by Zero Hedge, Goldman Sachs are shutting down their famed (or perhaps infamous), Global Alpha hedge fund. The obvious question posed by Zero Hedge is whose next? and I wonder which Australian fund(s), if any, will be hit.

Since the GFC when numerous Australian funds (mortgage, credit, hedge funds, and illiquid property funds) froze to redemptions, these funds have struggled as investors have sought increased transparency and lower cost investments (index funds, term deposits, and annuities). Because Australian investors haven’t jumped backed into these potentially illiquid and high risk funds I don’t there’s too much likelihood of another round of fund problems here. There may be the occasional hedge fund blow up (in fact I heard anecdotally about a start-up options trading hedge fund that blew up last month just a matter of months after starting), but given the relatively conservative appetite in Australia I think all should be ok (although Europe and US economies are still in deep doo-doo as is the Euro-sovereign and Euro currency situation)…I’ll let you know if I change my mind!

Sep 12

More on Asset weighted vs Time Weighted Returns

I just did some simple analysis of balanced fund returns and on a time weighted basis (excluding tax), balanced funds returned on average a compound monthly return of 0.38% in the ten years to the end of August 2011. This is equivalent of a compound annual growth rate of approximately 4.7%.

I then assumed the annual household income was around $70,000 and assumed the 9% superannuation contribution was added to a starting balance of $10,000 growing at around 3.6%pa across the same 10 year period. Low and behold it turns out the compound monthly return ended up being 0.33% which is the equivalent of approximately 4.06%pa.

So in this second scenario the average return dropped around 0.64%pa. This is because the worst returns over the last 10 years were in the latter half. So when they are applied to a larger balance the impact is far greater. Therefore, the risk your portfolio  takes as retirement approaches is critical as a nasty return shock when your balance is highest can be quite damaging to your retirement health.

Sep 10

A few thoughts on investment strategy for today

With the US heading towards recession and the Euro Sovereign Crisis getting ugly again where to invest one’s funds has never been tougher. Australian bonds yields are around 4%, meaning they are on PE ratio of 25 which compared to local and global shares, which are currently on forward PEs of around 10, are very expensive. Whilst shares are relatively better priced than bonds the additional volality makes them a challenging bet as downside certainly still exists.

My current thoughts around investment strategy are not so concerned with bonds versus shares but more around some style biases worth considering if you are looking to access each asset class.

Shares

  • I’m more inclined to favour “value” biased funds as growth stocks are currently gettng hammered if they don’t hit their numbers and they obviously have further to fall. The value style has a bias towards low PE or low Price/Book which certainly provides some downside protection in this market. The biggest risk to this bias is that alot of banks are probaly classified as value stocks but they are the ones most likely to suffer should the Euro Sovereign crisis develop into a Lehman Brothers’ type scenario
  • “Income” bias also appears a better bet. I personally like the Zurich Equity Income fund as it is typically much less volatile than the market but pays a very high income (it actually targets 10%pa in dividends). I’d certainly rather earn my returns from income than capital growth today.
  • In the Australian market I see one of the other big downside risks is in the small cap sector that may also be regarded as high growth and has a riskier exposure to commodities. Sure commodities appear to be good at the moment but their price increase has been so rapid that the downside in the face of a recession in the US is probably reasonably high. So underweight small cap in my book.

Fixed Interest

  • I definitely prefer Australian bonds than overseas. Whilst I’ve favoured Global Fixed interest funds in the past, with their high exposure to Italy and Spain it appears they have lost their defensive characteristics so I prefer active managers without too much exposure to the Euro sovereigns.
  • As opposed to 2008, I prefer diversified corporate credit (investment grade). The spreads are still quite wide and more than compensate for their default risk. Corporates around the world have been de-risking their balance sheets over the past few years and are relatively cashed up today so credit does appear good value.
  • Whilst the Australin government bond yield curve has dropped quite dramatically in the last couple of months the same can’t be said for term deposits. Whilst the term deposit interest rate has dropped it looks still quite attractive for any term up to 5 years….but be prepared to hunt around for a good deal…probably at a building society or credit union.

Its certainly a very tough investment environment today and next Saturday night I hope to do something a little more interesting than this!

 

Older posts «

» Newer posts