Apr 27
Australian Government Debt…not a worry
Apr 26
Risks of Fixed Interest Investments
One of the most misunderstood asset classes is fixed interest. Most investors have a reasonable understanding of the risks associated with equity investing but fixed interest is very different. I have created a draft article for use by advisers and discusses the major risks of fixed interest investment in the context of the global financial crisis and its various effects on last year’s returns. Quite simply, interest rate risks positive credit risks were negative, duration risks largely positive, and liquidity risks frustrating!
For those interested my article can be found here … http://tinyurl.com/ceba9j
Apr 21
Economic Outlook
At the time of writing, sharemarkets around the world have experienced one of their strongest six week rallies in history. The push to get the ball rolling was the $1trillion Geitner package that was designed to remove toxic assets from balance sheets. The G20 meeting of world leadersproduced one of the more productive outcomes in recent times and all of this was followed by surprised quarterly profit announcements from some of the biggest American banks in Goldman Sachs, and Citigroup. Whilst the newspapers and various commentators are calling the bottom of the market, there appears to be little evidence suggesting that things are looking up for the economy. The grim reality is that the major economic statistics released in recent weeks have been terrible.
Globally, the International Monetary Fund is predicting the first global GDP contraction since the great depression and that advanced economies will experience deflation during 2009. Deflation is where prices decrease and is just as concerning as high inflation as Japan in the 1990s will attest. For example if prices are declining then consumers are less inclined to spend as prices will be lower tomorrow. This obviously leads to lower profits, less jobs, less spending and the vicious cycle continues. Industrial production around the world is at record lows, credit is still expensive, andthe banks are still writing off enormous assets. Many of the leading economists in the US believe the $1trillion Geitner package is insufficient and should be more in the order of $4trillion otherwise the only hope for the US banks is nationalisation…but in the land of the free nationalisation of a bank is sacriligious.
In Australia, recent months have seen unemployment rapidly increase from just around 4.5% towards the end of 2008 to 5.4% at the end of February 2009. The federal government was forecasting unemployment to peak around 7% by mid 2010 and there is little doubt this figure will be revised upwards in the current budget. Whilst Australia is not technically in a recession (i.e. two consecutive quarters of negative growth) it is just a matter of weeks before a recession in Australia is confirmed. In fact, even before the GDP figures are released Kevin Rudd has announced that “it is inevitable that Australia is dragged into recession”.
The Australian government starting responding to the threats of recession several months ago by announcing their $42billion Nation Building and Jobs Plan, with around $30billion of this to be spent on infrastructure over the next few years. Compared to the rest of the world, the federal government has been very active in attempts to re-accelerate economic growth.
The first Tuesday in March saw the Reserve Bank decrease their cash rates by 0.25% to 3%, which again, compared to the rest of the world is one of the largest and most rapid of interest rate reductions. Unfortunately, whilst bank cash accounts reduced interest rates the same cannot be said for home loans where only a small proportion of the rate cut was passed onto borrowers. In longer term interest rate markets we have seen government bond yields increase substantially in recent weeks. This increase is due to the government required capital raisings to fund their future debt and once again this is not helping those that wish to fix their home loan interest rates. Commonwealth bank announced that they are increasing their fixed rate for all mortgages with terms greater than 1 year.
The outlook for interest rates are further reductions. The Australian government bond maturing in September this year currently trades on a yield of 2.77% indicating at least one and most likely two reductions of 0.25% over the next few months.
Chart 1
The outlook for equity markets both here and overseas continues to be one of volatility. Whilst valuations (as defined by the PE Ratio) continues to be at low levels (Chart 1), the expected decline in earnings (Chart 2) and lack of earnings guidance from companies both in Australia and around the world provides significant uncertainty of potential. As chart 2 shows future earnings expectations are to be below 2005/06 and 2006/07 levels.
Chart 2

With low cash rates, volatile equity and bond markets, and continued economic uncertainty, diversification of investment portfolios is essential. Compared to the rest of the world the Australian economy is better positioned to withstand the slowdown. The government has one of the lowest debt levels in the world and the Reserve Bank still has significant room to move on interest rates. These factors provide opportunity to add further stimulus to our economy to provide jobs and economic growth. Whilst Australia is probably already in recession these factors suggest the slowdown won’t be as bad here as in the rest of the world.
Apr 16
Putting this bear market in perspective
Apr 14
Is the market cheap?

The above chart is a couple of weeks old now but is showing the market PE ratio to be around 11 (so its probably 12 now). As the chart shows this is a PE ratio that was pretty much the average throughout the 70s and early 80s. Now a PE of 11 is an earnings yield of 9% and if we expect negative growth of say 1% then we’re left with an 8% earnings yield over the next 12 months. With the government bond yield at around 3% is 5% really a sufficient risk premium? With BBB rated corporate bonds with an average credit spread of at least 5% I’m not really sure the current PE ratio really stacks up as attractive given the incredible headwinds Australian companies are facing…many may say the market’s cheap and maybe a PE of 11 (or 12) is cheap…but not yet.
Apr 08
Groucho Marx and the 1929 Crash
“Some of the people I know lost millions. I was luckier. All I lost was two hundred and forty thousand dollars… I would have lost more but that was all the money I had.”….Groucho Marx writing in “Groucho & Me”
Apr 08
Credit Crisis Continues…

Whilst the Reserve Bank drops their cash interest rates the credit spreads (as shown above) on investment grade corporate bonds are doing the opposite. It doesn’t matter whether you are a AA, A, or BBB rated corporate you are paying a record interest rate above the government interest rates. It amazing that these credit spreads are almost 2% higher than when Lehman Brothers collapsed. Anyway…I guess this chart explains to a degree why the banks have barely pass on any of yesterday’s interest rate cut…because credit is still very tight.
Apr 07
Traps of Capital Protected Investments
Capital protected investments are getting more and more popular in these economically uncertain times. There are quite a few varieties of capital protected products and on the surface many of them look very attractive however most come with a few hidden traps. This article doesn’t explain all of the traps but a few of the more common ones.
Some examples include:
- 100% protection and 100% exposure to growth of the S&P/ASX200 index…this is a very common structure where the protection comes from the purchase of a zero coupon bond and the index exposure comes from the purchase of a call option. The trap is that the exposure is only capital growth and excludes any franked dividends that the S&P/ASX200 may pay. The current dividend yield of the S&P/ASX200 index is around 7.2% and if we assume a significant drop to 5% dividends over the next 12 months plus some franking then this is a hefty price to pay for the pleasure of capital protection.
- 100% capital protection and 100% exposure to both growth and dividends of an underlying index or managed fund…this particular capital protected product uses an insurance method commonly called CPPI (Constant Proportion Portfolio Insurance) or Dynamic Threshold Management. Basically, if the underlying index or managed fund drops below a certain price, it is sold and low risk bonds are purchased to ensure the capital is protected. There are two traps with this method. Trap One…in very volatile markets and low interest rate environments this method is prone to failure. This is because a sudden drop in the price of the underlying may not given the protection manager sufficient time to sell at the right price to ensure protection. This leads to counterparty risk so ensuring the provider can pay up is essential. Trap Two…this method is inefficient as growth assets are sold when low and bought back when prices are high. This seriously dilutes the final return.
- 100% Protected Index Linked Deferred Purchase Agreement…there are a few products available at the moment where for a deposit of around $5,000 to $7,000 an investor can obtain a 100% protected exposure to $50,000 in an index such as the S&P/ASX200 with a cap on the upside of between 20% and 30%. There are several traps with this product…
Trap One…the same as point 1 above applies, that is, the index exposure excludes dividends. Trap Two…the payment is in fact an insurance premium payment and not an installment or actual investment so like any insurance payment it is a cost that is immediately lost. Trap Three…the price. The investor is actually purchasing an “At the money” call option plus selling an “Out of the Money” call option with a strike price 20%-30% above the current index price. Using option pricing methods such as Black & Scholes at current volatility levels this structure should cost around 5%-7% at most but the actual cost is 10%-14% (($5,000 to $7,000)/$50,000)…quite a hefty profit for the product provider and quite a high return required (without dividends) just to get the premium back.
Unfortunately, due to their complexity capital protected investments lack a lot of pricing transparency and in these volatile times cost a lot of money. Always keep in mind that capital protected products are unlikely to replicate sharemarket returns and are expected to provide a diluted return. Due to these factors it is typically more efficient to invest into a balanced portfolio of numerous asset classes.
Apr 07






