Jun 12

Australia’s Steep Yield Curve

An incredible steepening of the yield curve has occurred throughout 2009. As can be seen the latest 10 year bond yield isn’t too far from where it was in the middle of 2008. This yield curve tells us several things about the state of current markets and economy…

  • the market is starting to think that the next RBA move will be an increase in interest rates and not a drop…the 3 month yield is only 2.95% versus the 3% cash rate and longer term yields are above 3%
  • The steep normal looking yield curve is typically a sign that Australia’s economy is looking up and this steepening has increased throughout the year in line with increasingly positive news
  • The sharp increase in steepness has happened so quickly….does this mean that bonds are oversold?

Overall this is a good looking positive yield curve despite global economic news continuing to be mixed. We are still in the ‘green shoots’ phase of a global economic recovery so this steep yield curve looks to be a relatively attractive buying opportunity to me.

Jun 12

The safest investment strategy

I have just read an article by Zvi Bodie, who has authroed a few university investment texts, and he reminds us of a simple but unfortunately forgotten or ignored concept…

“Matching is the safest investment strategy for achieving a specific goal. To eliminate the risk of falling short of an investment goal at a specific future date, the investor needs to match the maturity of his investments to the date of his goal, with target dated, inflation protected investments” like inflation linked bonds.

Government Inflation linked bonds is the only true risk free investment…does anyone actually realise this fact???

Jun 11

Style Biased Index Funds – the Future of Managed Funds

Index funds were born out of modern portfolio theory which suggested that the highest risk-adjusted return should come from purchasing the market portfolio. As it is impossible to purchase market as a whole, the index fund effectively replicates the market by purchasing a large proportion of the market with each stock’s weighting proportional to its market capitalisation. Around the world, this method has been replicated across all asset classes. In Australia, the available index funds are mostly limited to the major asset classes. Some geographic index funds, like BRIC, China, S&P500, etc are also available as well as specific sub asset classes like Global Credit index funds. There is little doubt index funds provide a low-cost way of providing investors exposure to specific markets without the active management risk of the ‘bad bet’.

The current bear market has resulted in many investors looking for simplicity, transparency, and low costs and index funds satisfy all criteria. Whilst many wealth and funds management companies have suffered during the Global Financial Crisis, index funds have thrived. Barclay’s have released a wide array of listed international index funds, Vanguard also released some exchange traded funds and only yesterday announced they are moving into larger premises and hiring an additional 8 sales professionals. And now, in Australia the index fund has another variety with the introduction of Research Associates’ Fundamental Index (RAFI) and various investment products linked to this index approach.

In recent weeks I have received more queries regarding this new index method than anything else (except the ubiquitous structured product). It is marketed as an alternative to traditional index funds and its difference is that it doesn’t use a company’s market capitalisation as the weighting determinant but uses measures such as sales, profits, dividends, amongst others. The founders of RAFI believe traditional indices overweight overpriced stocks and underweight underpriced stocks and they believe this new method overcomes this flaw. Despite the strong support the fundamental index has received locally and overseas, there have been many critics.

The main criticisms of the Fundamental index method are that it resembles an ‘active value strategy in disguise’ requiring numerous subjective decisions around stock selection. As a result of this, many believe the fundamental index is not efficient when compared to multi-factor quantitative strategies. Even if these arguments are true, at this point in time they are fruitless arguments in Australia because accessing passive strategies that are different but priced similarly to traditional index funds are few and far between (the one exception is DFA which is not necessarily easy to access as an adviser). At least the fundamental index investments are around 40bps cheaper than active equity managers and this is a significant cost saving over the long term. With this cost saving if its stated return premium is due to a value bias then as long as this bias/risk is understood there is nothing wrong with that. With the exception of the DFA funds, to achieve a value bias typically costs a lot more than the RAFI funds.

Back to the critics opinions…belief in the so-called efficiency of multi-factor quantitative strategies creates an opportunity in the Australian funds management industry. Globally, it is widely acknowledged that over the ‘long term’, equity portfolios biased towards…

• low price to book,
• small companies, and more recently,
• companies exhibiting performance momentum (i.e. performed well over the last 3 to 12 months)

…outperform traditional indices on a risk-adjusted basis. Accessing these style biases in low cost ways cannot easily be achieved in Australia for the retail investor. Perhaps this is the future of equity index investment in Australia.

For the active manager style biased index funds will be a significant threat. The active manager will have new truly investible benchmarks and they will have to prove their skill against low cost funds with similar style biases. This in turn could reduce costs due to increased competition and only the strong will remain. The active manager often hides behind their style bias when underperformance occurs, however, with style biased index funds in direct competition this will not be an excuse.

The introduction of the fundamental index products are an excellent addition to the Australian managed fund scene and moving forward I look forward to seeing more low cost, style biased index funds to provide more efficiency and choice for the retail investment portfolio.

May 23

Another financial product rant

As I sit down to write another article, Great Southern has just collapsed and I have been asked to speak to some Financial Planners about structured products. If the Global Financial Crisis has taught us anything or confirmed what we already know, it’s that we must avoid investing in anything we don’t understand and avoid high commission or high fee charging investment products. Unlike other industries, in ours the higher the cost very rarely means you are receiving higher quality as the Agribusiness, Hedge Fund and Structured Products have shown. Each of these sub-asset classes are also not the easiest investments to understand.

Both Timbercorp and Great Southern’s collapse have created enormous anxiety for the investor as there is still significant uncertainty as to what they are likely to receive from their initial investment or where they stand in terms of ongoing commitments. The complexity of these companies’ promises and structures will soon come to light but it appears the administrators are still coming to grips with them also.

Whilst there have been a few hedge fund collapses and closures, the current bear market has exposed them as funds that still have exposure to market risks, whether credit, equities, bonds, etc. and that their promise of positive returns in any market was simply a marketing line as the average global hedge fund or main hedge fund indices returned around -20% for the 2008 year. When you add their lack of liquidity and, for some, their recent suspension, compared to the more traditional managed funds their performance is even more disappointing.

Finally we have the structured products that promise capital protection or limited losses whilst still providing the investors exposure to the performance potential of various sharemarkets. In terms of complexity and hidden fees, structured products may well take the prize.

There is one particularly product I have reviewed in recent weeks that I find astonishing. I’m even more astonished that it received the second highest rating from one of Australia’s leading research houses. In its most conservative form (in terms of maximum loss), at first read, for an investment of around $6,000 the investor will receive $50,000 exposure to the Australian sharemarket (ASX200) and after 2 years receives a maximum return of $9,250 (or ~18.5% of the $50000 exposure) and at worst, nothing (if the ASX200 has a zero or negative performance over the 2 years).

For many prospective investors this type of investment may sound quite appealing, particularly if bullish on the ASX200 index, as only an 18.5% return over 2 years is required to be what appears to be a return of more than 150% on the initial investment. Unfortunately, in this case, looks are very deceiving.

Firstly, the $6,000 investment is in fact a payment for an options position (as opposed to an initial investment) and can only be recovered if the ASX200 returns 12% over the 2 years (i.e. 12% of $50,000 equals $6,000). The options position being purchased is the purchase of one call option with a strike price of $50,000 and selling another call option with a strike price of $59,250 that matures in 2 years.

Secondly, because the exposure is the ASX200 index and not the ASX200 Accumulation index, the investor receives no exposure to dividends, let alone franked dividends. Given the current dividend yield of the Australian sharemarket is around 7%, if we assume a conservative forward dividend yield of 5%, then just to get your initial investment back, the ASX200 (including dividends) needs to return 11% (that is, 6% capital growth plus the 5% dividend).

Over the last 25 years, the ASX200 Accumulation Index has returned just over 9% and over 25 years, 10.93%. If we look at the index in question, the ASX200 Share Price Index, its 20 year performance is approximately 4.6% and over 25 years is 6.45%. So what initially may have appeared an attractive structured product in fact requires above average returns just to get your money back.

I have never seen more demand for structured products than now. Unfortunately, many of these are simply fee grabs by the investment banks who issue them as they take advantage of the risk aversion many investors now have after suffering significant sharemarket losses. I urge all adviser take significant care when looking at structured products. For most investors they would probably be better off investing in a simple well-diversified fund with a 50/50 split between growth and defensive assets…don’t forget this structure also has limited downside whilst providing sharemarket exposure.

May 16

Default Super Funds

There’s been a little bit of publicity lately about the makeup of default super funds. I don’t have any statistics but my understanding is that most default super funds are the balanced fund which, strangely, is 70% invested in growth assets like shares and property. Given the overall lack of understanding of investment risk in our community this, to me, is obviously a far too risky portfolio to be the default fund for the average decision-shy employee. I read a letter to the Financial Review earlier in the week that suggested the default fund should be cash, due to its riskless nature. My guess is that the balanced fund has been chosen as it is perceived to be well diversified and with sufficient growth assets to outpace inflation. Inflation, of course, is the biggest risk associated with cash and bonds. Anyway, so where am I heading with this?

 

To me, both cash and the balanced fund are not appropriate as the default fund for the already stated reasons…1) the balanced fund is too risky and not appropriately matched to most people’s risk profile, and 2) cash (or bonds) are not appropriate due to the risks of inflation.

 

So what is my suggestion? Inflation Linked Bonds…that way the inflation risk is removed and the uninformed are not exposed to the massive volatility of sharemarkets.

May 15

Thought of the Day

If the risks of investing in the sharemarket are supposed to be lower the longer you invest, then why does it cost more to insure the same sharemarket portfolio (using put options) the longer your timeframe? Answer…because the first part of the statement is false and sharemarket risk does not decline over time

May 06

Market Valuation Update


Source: RBA

The rise in global sharemarkets in the last 2 months has seen the PE Ratio increase from its bottom at around 10 to around 12 to 13. As the above chart shows this ratio valuation level is not too different to the average PE Ratio in the 1970s and for Australia, the 1970s and 1980s.

With the global adn local economy still forecast to shrink in 2009, company profits expected to drop significantly, the current PE ratio still does not look cheap and significant downside risks remain on valuation alone.

May 05

Today’s RBA Rate Prediction

The current September 2009 government bond is yielding 2.77% indicating the market is expecting (most likely) only one more 25bps rate reduction over the next few months. Most economists expect the RBA to stay steady today and given the RBA reduced rates last month by 25bps I also expect it to stay steady as they have indicated in the past their desire to see how their actions are received before reducing again.

The budget is only one week away and it may be packed with enough goodies to provide the economy with a boost but no matter what, the global problems will still overwhelm the Australian government’s action so there’s a long way to go. With inflationary expectations still very low, I see no reason why the RBA shouldn’t cut rates, but I still expect a 3% cash rate tomorrow.

Apr 28

US House Price Data…down again

Because the current global financial crisis started with declining US House prices many believe that it will finish with improving US House prices. The primary index used in the US that assesses house price movement is the Case-Shiller Composite Index. As can be seen unfortunately the plummet in prices continued in February and prices fell to 2003 levels.

Apr 28

Risks of Direct Equity Portfolios

This week my latest education article was published in IFA magazine. Basically it summarises the amount of additional downside risk a direct equities portfolio with a small number of stocks takes on compared to portfolio with a large number of stocks. There is myth that concentrated stock portfolios are more likely to outperform managed funds, an index, or a larger stock portfolio. This myth appears every bear market and must be exposed for what it is…rubbish.

If you can’t get the magazine, never mind as the article can be found by clicking on the following link… http://tinyurl.com/dmq7da

Older posts «

» Newer posts