Jul 17

How many bank failures?

Just back from holidays with a week off…anyway…another couple of bank failures in the US…First Piedmont Bank, Winder, Georgia and BankFirst, Sioux Falls, South Dakota …these
are the 54th and 55th banks to collapse in the US since the start of this “Great Recession”.

Other interesting US economic points of note…

  • The state of Michigan (home of the US Car Industry) has the highest unemployment in the US at 15.2%; Rhode Island has the second highest unemployment level at 12.4%
  • FOMC (a component of the Federal Reserve) staff revised up its projection for the increase in real GDP in 2010, to a pace above the growth rate of potential GDP. As a consequence, the staff projected that the unemployment rate would rise further in 2009 but would edge down in 2010. Meanwhile, the staff forecast for inflation was marked up.

Jul 08

Mutual Fund Theorem – Ignored by most financial advisers

According to John Campbell, Professor of Finance at Harvard, “academic finance has had a remarkable impact on many financial services. Yet, financial planners offering portfolio advice to long-term investors have received curiously little guidance from academic financial economists”.
A case in point is the Mutual Fund Theorem, which was developed by Nobel Laureate, James Tobin in 1958. The mutual fund theorem is a very simple approach to investing based around Harry Markowitz’s efficient frontier framework suggesting that all investors should hold only one portfolio of risky assets. This one portfolio can then be adjusted for the conservative investor by adding risk free assets (or cash), or can be geared for the aggressive investor.
The figure above shows the efficient frontier and the Capital Market Line (CML) which is drawn from the expected return of Cash through the tangent of the efficient frontier (represented by the Optimal Portfolio). Whilst it is not a perfect representation of reality, it demonstrates the possibilities that:
  • By adding cash (or a risk free asset) to the optimal portfolio (which contains bonds, equities, etc) it is possible to achieve a high return for less risk than a portfolio of bonds…this is the benefit of diversification
  • Gearing the optimal portfolio has the ability to achieve a high risk-adjust return than a portfolio of 100% equities. Most of the high growth portfolios include only equities (which clearly may be less efficient than a geared diversified (or optimal) portfolio)

Whilst most if not all financial planners and advisers are aware of the Markowitz efficient frontier and the derivation of the optimal portfolio (i.e. the portfolio with the highest expected return per unit risk), the use of this very simple part of modern portfolio theory has seldom been put into practice. Financial planners throughout the world typically look to personalise portfolios for individual clients based on their risk profile, income and growth needs and most likely looking to build portfolios that are on the efficient frontier. As Figure 1 shows, in theory this may not be the most efficient approach and is potentially creating unnecessary work that adds little to no value in terms of what matters to investors the most, investment returns.

From a practical financial planning perspective, adding cash or gearing an “optimal portfolio” certainly makes things a lot simpler.

Now whilst every investment professional in the world attempts to design an optimal portfolio within their constrained investment universe, we all know that it is impossible, but of course, it doesn’t stop us from trying. For the retail investor the optimal portfolio is often regarded as the “balanced” portfolio, which has a diversified allocation across all available asset classes whether equities, bonds, real assets, etc.

So to really keep portfolio construction simple, recommend the “balanced” fund for the balanced investor and add cash for the more conservative investors and gear into the balanced fund for the growth and high growth investor.

Some of the challenges with implementation include, choosing the optimal portfolio; the limitations of implementation in various investment vehicles such as superannuation where gearing may be difficult; or simply getting cost effective gearing.

Overall, this theorem should provide some food for thought next time a portfolio is constructed and some questions to ask before building the next “tailored” portfolio could be…can a geared diversified portfolio be more efficient than 100% equities or should the client really be out of equities just because they are conservative? At the very least, the Mutual Fund Theorem demonstrates the best method to manage risk is diversification and diversification across all asset classes should be considered irrespective of the investor’s risk profile.

Jul 05

Hedge Funds vs Banks

Whlst hedge funds have their problems, thanks to lack of transparency, high fees, etc; lets never forget that hedge funds did not cause this global financial crisis…banks did

Jul 01

Is there value in inflation linked bonds?

The RBA provides daily reporting on three Treasury Capital Indexed bonds. They each mature in the month of August in 2010, 2015, and 2020 and are currently yielding 2.40%, 3.11%, and 3.02% respectively as at 30th June 2009. If we compare these Capital Indexed yields to the Treasure Fixed Rate yields for similar maturing securities we achieve the market’s estimation of inflation over the term to maturity.

The yield of the Treasury Fixed Rate Coupon Bond maturing August 2010 is 3.45% indicating the expected inflation through to August 2010 is 1.05% (i.e. 3.45% – 2.40%) which is clearly very low.

Applying the same logic using April 2015 and April 2020 Fixed Rate Bond yields of 5.32% and 5.62% respectively we achieve an inflation outlook of 2.21% and 2.60% over each respective term.

The inflation outlook is:

  • 1.05% to August 2010
  • ~2.21% over the next 6 years to 2015, and
  • ~2.60% over the next 11 years to 2020

Whilst I agree that inflation is likely to be relatively low over the coming years, for the fixed rate investor, inflation will always be a significant risk. If you invest in a government bond yielding 5.62%pa over the next 11 years high inflation could easily wipe out any value in this type of investment. As a result, despite, these subdued inflation outlooks, there appears to be significant long term value in inflation linked bonds whilst yields appear to be at historically low levels and also whilst the outlook for inflation appears low.

The risk for the inflation linked bond investor is that inflation turns out to be even lower than the above-mentioned forecast…if you think inflation will be lower than stick to the fixed rate bond, otherwise inflaiton linked bonds are definnitely worth serious consideration.

Jul 01

US House Prices


Source: www.calculatedrisk.com

I last published this chart two months ago and the trend has not abated. US House prices continue to decline and are currently around February 2003 levels. Include inflation and the housing prices are even lower.

I guess some of the lessons in this include:

  • never take increasing house prices for granted like many of us do in Australia
  • household wealth in the US continues to decline whilst their biggest asset continues to decline in value
  • the economic crisis is not over yet

With continued declines this will probably mean more people defaulting on their loans and more problems for the US banks. Whilst a handful of banks have paid back some of their TARP money there are still a few that haven’t yet. This housing problem is part of a vicious cycle that needs to stop so hopefully the fiscal stimulus in the US will kick in soon.

Jun 30

An Argument for Global Diversification

With Australia having the second worst returns amongst the above-mentioned OECD countries this clearly shows the benefits of having a portfolio that was diversified globally during 2008. Even in the USA, the originator of the global financial crisis had better returns than in Australia.

Jun 26

Paul Krugman on the GFC

Whilst the following statement from Paul Krugman is taken from a debate on how to deal with the global financial crisis and is quite a few weeks old. It still applies and is an excellent description of the current state of the Global Financial Crisis and why interest rates should stay relatively low despite massive budget deficitis from governments around the world…

Let’s think about what is actually happening to the global economy right now. On the one side there has been an abrupt realization by many people that they have too much debt, that they are not as rich as they thought. US households have seen their net worth decline abruptly by $13 trillion, and there are similar blows occurring around the world. So the people, individual households, want to save again. The United States has gone from approximately a zero savings rate two years ago up to about 4 percent right now, which is still below historical norms; but suddenly saving is occurring.

That saving ought to be translated into investment, but the investment demand is not there. Housing is flat on its back because it was overbuilt; housing bubbles collapsed not only in the United States, but across much of Europe. Many businesses cannot get access to capital because of the breakdown of the financial system. But even those that do have access to capital don’t want to invest because consumer demand is not there. Between the housing bust and the sudden decision of consumers to save, after all, we have a world with lots of excess capacity. The GDP report that just came out says that business-fixed investment, non-residential fixed investment, essentially business investment, is falling at a 40 percent annual rate.

This causes a problem. There are lots of people who want to save, creating a vast increase in savings, not only in the US but around the world, combined with a sharp decline in the amount that the private sector is willing to invest, even at a zero interest rate, or rather even at a zero interest rate for US government debt, which is what the Federal Reserve has the most direct impact on.

One way to think about the global crisis is a vast excess of desired savings over willing investment. We have a global savings glut. Another way to say it is we have a global shortage of demand. Those are equivalent ways of saying the same thing. So we have this global savings glut, which is why there is, in fact, no upward pressure on interest rates. There are more savings than we know what to do with. If we ask the question “Where will the savings come from to finance the large US government deficits?,” the answer is “From ourselves.” The Chinese are not contributing at all.

Those extra savings are, in effect, the savings that America has wanted to make anyway, but that US business is not willing to invest under current conditions. That is the way Keynesian policy works in the short run. It takes excess desired savings and translates them into some kind of spending. If the private sector won’t do it, the government will. There is actually no contradiction between the Federal Reserve’s actions and the actions of the US government with a fiscal stimulus. It’s very much necessary to do both. By buying a lot of private securities, the Federal Reserve is essentially going out there and playing the role that the private banking system is no longer playing properly; by engaging in investment, the federal government is playing the role that businesses are not now willing to play. All that debt-financed spending on infrastructure by the Obama administration is basically filling the hole left by the collapse in business investment in the United States. There is not an excess demand for savings that is going to drive up interest rates. The only thing that might drive up interest rates—and this is a real concern—is that people may grow dubious about the financial solvency of governments.

Now, the great concern I have is that although we understand these things fairly well, there are thirty-eight Republican senators who say that the answer for the crisis is another round of Bush-style tax cuts that will reduce revenues by $3 trillion over the next decade.

This crisis has been so large and the political process has been so sluggish that the difficulties have been greater than expected. And yes, there are some green shoots. Things are getting worse more slowly, but we have not managed to head off a crisis that could turn out to be self-reinforcing, and leave us in this trap for many, many years.

We are a little isolated in Australia and there’s little doubt we are positioned better than other countries around the world, but at the end of the day we are part of the global economy still in crisis so we should not be complacent and think all is well. For what its worth, in my opinion we have a long way to go yet. Markets have been responding sharply to the slightest bit of good news but whilst the crisis was created over many years, it will not be over in just a few months. Hang on for a rollercoaster ride.

Jun 24

Benchmarks

One of the things that annoys me when I’m analyising managed fund performance is their chosen bechmarks. I’m of the belief that a managed fund benchmark should have the following attributes…
  • Investable
  • Realistic
  • Replicable
  • a reflection of the fund’s investable universe

Unfortunately there are numerous funds out there that have benchmarks that fail these key attributes and have benchmarks based on marketing or investor needs. For example, many hedge funds have had an annual positive return benchmark even though they are largely exposed to equity or credit markets.

This week I have seen global listed infrastructure funds that benchmark to CPI plus x% and this is also the case for numerous multi-manager investment funds and the benchmark of asset allocations set by the numerous asset consultants and research agencies.

What a ludicrous benchmark CPI plus or annual positive return benchmarks are for funds that are exposed to equity markets. High inflation is not good for equities and neither is deflation so the relationship is weak. If I want to beat CPI I can just invest in an inflation linked bonds.

Equity markets are so volatile that at any stage the equity markets will be outperforming a stated positive return so a positive return benchmark is surely just a way of increasing fees for the manager on the back of the belief in the equity premium.

Overall, if a fund’s benchmark does not reflect their investible universe and it cannot be replicated for investment then the fund will be dismissed by me. The role of an active manager is to outperform its benchmark after adjusting for risk (and fees). When a benchmark doesn’t reflect a fund’s actual risk then iits time to dismiss the fund as an investment consideration.

Jun 19

A simple economic/financial update for some planners

Over the past few months the global economy has seen the emergence of “green shoots”. As implied, there are indications that the global economy may be turning a corner. Like turning around a super tanker, turning around the global economy will take a long time and these signs aren’t so much an improvement but indicate a slowdown in the deterioration of the global economy. For example, in the US only 345,000 jobs were lost during May which is around half the average monthly decline of the previous six months. US Unemployment is still increasing but not at the rate it previously was.

Other positives include the gradual decline in the cost of credit (remember the Global Financial Crisis started as a credit crisis), stabilising financial markets, perceived future demand resulting in increasing commodity prices (Oil increased by 48% in USD terms over the past 3 months), and improving consumer confidence.

In Australia, our unemployment stands at 5.7% and the Australian Bureau of Statistics announced that we avoided a technical recession to the quarter ending March 2009 with positive real GDP Growth of 0.4% thanks to declining imports.

For the Australian sharemarket investor, returns for the 3 months ending May 2009 have been spectacular with the broad All Ordinaries Accumulation index increasing by a little more than 17%. Overseas sharemarkets also provided strong returns and the major sharemarket indices of the US, UK, and Japan increased by 25%, 15% and 25% respectively. With the Australian dollar appreciating over the same 3 months against the US Dollar, Pound, and Yen, by 25%, 11%, and 22% only the hedged international investor experienced the strong international gains as the strength of the Aussie dollar most of these returns.

The perceived improvement in the global economy combined with large budget deficits all around the world including here in Australia, government bond yields increased substantially. This means that investment returns for the bond investor were relatively weak (as high interest rates mean lower bond prices). The UBS Composite Bond index had a slightly negative return of -0.6% for the 3 months to May 31, and the global fixed interest index, JP Morgan Broad WGBI (AUD) Hedged Index, returned only 0.43%.

Whilst the short term sharemarket gains indicate positive signs for both the Global and Australian economy, there are still significant signs of weakness. Unemployment both here and overseas is still increasing which will continue to dampen demand and force households into increased savings instead of spending. Business investment is weak and companies continue to struggle, as evidenced with the recent collapse of General Motors and Chrysler in the US, and two of the largest agribusiness companies in Australia, Timbercorp and Great Southern. The last few months have shown the risks of being out of the sharemarket when everything appears to be at their worst. For investors, sticking to a portfolio with the risk profile designed to help achieve financial goals is essential.

Jun 13

Misquoted in the Financial Review

I’m typically a little nervous about interviews with journalists because you never know how they may use your comments and its not always 100% clear as to specifically what they’re writing about.

Lucky me had my photo and was quoted in today’s Financial Review article on inflation linked bonds written by Brendon Lau (page 42 if you’re interested). Unfortunately the article suggetsed that I am “convinced that if retirement investors had access to a deeper and richer inflaiton-linked bond market, their retirement savings would not been as badly devastated by the global financial crisis”.

I don’t recall saying anything of the sort and nor do I believe it. Maybe if retirement investors were more conservative and invested in AAA rated government bonds whether inflation-linked or not insted of equities and property then their retirement savings would not have been devastated. But that is a question of risk profile…not as to whether there was a deeper and richer inflation-linked bond market.

Older posts «

» Newer posts