If you are interested in an educational article on the main risks a bond investor faces and how those risks have played out over the past year or two, please visit this link.
Sep 03
Economic Growth does not mean High Equity Returns
One of the more frequent queries I receive is from planners who want to invest their client’s funds into high economic growth countries of India, China, and emerging markets. My response is fairly standard in that I wonder why they believe that would provide their clients and the response is typically along the lines of “their growth potential is greater than the rest of the world”.
Last week, one of my favourite bloggers, Buttonwood (The Economist), provided commentary on this phenomenon, titled “The Growth Illusion“. I know I’m doubling up and perhaps you can read it yourself but in essence, “the faster an economy grows does not mean the faster corporate profits grow and therefore the investor receives higher returns”. A study performed performed by Dimson, Marsh and Staunton (they’re a few academics involved in the production of Credit Suisse’s Global Investment Returns Yearbook this year), showed that there was in fact a “negative correlation between investment returns and growth in GDP per capita, the best measure of how rich people are getting”…so no go there.
A second study showed that the better returns from 1990 to 2005 did not come from the highest growth economies. And a third study showed “no statistical link between one year GDP growth rate and the next year’s investment returns”.
Another study by Paul Marson of Lombard Odier, showed there is no correlation between GDP Growth and Stockmarket returns of Emerging Markets.
The most likely reasons for all of this rests with a few reasons stated in the Buttonwood blog…
- the potential is already recognised and factored into prices so that they are bid up to very high levels
- the stock market does not represent a country’s economy and vice versa
- “growth is siphoned off by insiders at the risk of shareholders”
The best recent example I can think of is China. It may have had one of the best growth rates in 2008 but the sharemarket still crashed by 70%. With all of this good news flowing through for the month of August China’s stockmarket was still down 20% (albeit up by 70% beforehand). Maybe investing in a growth economy will produce the good or maybe it won’t, but as the first point above alludes to…everyone knows this so why wouldn’t it already be priced in?
Aug 27
Bond Fund Correlations
The above chart shows the 6 month daily correlation between Hedged Global Shares and four Australian bond funds…
- Tyndall Australian Bond
- UBS International Bond
- Macquarie Diversified Fixed Interest
- Principal Global Strategic Income Fund
Each fund is different. Tyndall is invested in high grade Australian bonds, UBS International in high grade global bonds, Macquarie is 60% Australian bonds, 40% global and also takes on some investment grade credit risks, and Principal’s fund invests in high yielding securities including hybrids, asset backed securities, junk bonds, as well as some conservative bonds. All global exposures are hedged to Australian dollars.
What this chart demonstrates is the increasing correlation between Principal and hedged international shares from mid 2007, the start of the credit crunch. Basically, diversification benefits did not really exist for the high yielding investment.
However for the other funds, which had conservative bonds as a high proportion, their low correlation with hedge international shares shows their diverisifcation benefits in tact.
So a simple conclusion is…whilst high yielding investment may giove you the opportunity for higher returns, don’t think they will provide diversification benefits if sharemarkets tank. With a weak outlook for shares, so too is the outlook for companies to pay their debt so the price of low-grade credit can fall significantly also. A final point, which is often overlooked…bonds have limited upside…at maturity the most you will ever receive is the face value…that’s it.
Aug 21
World Government Bonds perform best over last 5 years
The above table shows the returns for various subclasses of fixed interest from the perspective of the Australian investor (i.e. in Austrlaian dollars) through to the end of June 2009. As can be seen, the World Government Bond index hedged to Australian dollars has been the winner over the last 3 and 5 years. High Yield, as expected given the widening of credit spreads over the last 2 years, comes in last.
Disappointingly, the Morningstar index of bond fund managers fall quite short versus their respecitve indices. For example, Morningstar Australian Bond managers perform significanlty worse than the UBS Composite index and the Morningstar Global Bond managers perform well below the BarCap Global Aggregate index.
Aug 06
Yield Curve looking Good…is it too good?
As the above chart shows, the Australian government yield curve has been steepening ever since the end of last year. This yield curve is a good indicator of the future strength of the AUstralian economy. As it shows, during June of 2008 the curve was negative (i.e. sloping downwards) and worst case scenario, is that a negative yield curve signals potential recession as there is no premium for long term rates like you would expect. Right now, 5 August, the curve is incredible steep with current interest rates at 3% and 5 year government bonds yielding around 5.5%. This curve indicates there is only one direction for rates to go and that is up…and that is only likely to occur if the economy is strong.
There is no doubt the outlook for the Australian economy and global economy) has improved in recent months, but the speed of the improvement, whether sharemarkets or the strengthening of the above yield curve, has been startling. Whilst yields aren’t what they used to be, has this rapid improvement been to fast, so is there a short term opportunity for bonds? If not, then can this yield curve get steeper?
Aug 03
Apples and Oranges of Volatility
My latest IFA educational article can be found here.
Recently I met with a fund manager who was showing me how his direct property fund had lower volatility than the listed property index. Given the infrequency of direct property valuation, volatility measures, like standard deviation, should probably be ignored.
My latest article published in IFA magazine simply shows how volatility can be manipulated and mis-used…just like my friendly direct property fund manager.
Aug 03
Alpha does not equal Outperformance
An article I wrote earlier in the year for IFA magazine can now be found here. Basically the article shows how it is possible to outperform and index but display no skill (or alpha); and vice versa…i.e. underperform an index and show skill (or alpha).
Aug 03
Another blow for active managers
Following the APRA report from a few weeks ago, late last week Standard and Poors published a paper that wasn’t too flattering of the active side of the Australian funds management industry. The paper can be found here.
Their analysis had the following conclusions:
- Over 5 years, the benchmarks outperformed the majority of active managers
- ASX/S&P200 index outperformed two-thirds of active Australian general equity funds
- UBS Composite 0+ Bond index outperformed more than 97% of actively managed bond funds over the last 5 years
- Between 10% to 30% of all funds have disappeared over the last 5 years
A fascinating, but unsurprising result of which most in fund research or academia have known for a long time. The most surprising result is that it has come from Standard and Poors who are potentially damaging their own business (albeit in a very small way) by suggesting that active management, on average, fails.
I guess Standard and Poors will be suggesting that it requires their skill to pick the best managers!!!
Jul 24
A unique view on Goldman Sachs
Another hilarious video…Max Keiser clearly hates the house of Sachs…[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSwWy4E6I04&hl=en&fs=1&]
Jul 17
Financial Guru…Lenny Dykstra
This is both hilarious & tragic all at the same time…
| The Daily Show With Jon Stewart | Mon – Thurs 11p / 10c | |||
| Lenny Dykstra’s Financial Career | ||||
|
||||
and the link in case it doesn’t work is here
