May 12

Perpetual Portfolio Manager’s Interesting View

I just had a meeting with Charlie Lanchester, who manages half of Perpetual’s massive Industrial Share Fund, and his views on the Australian economy were far more dire than many commentators are saying. Like many, he believes that commodity prices are very high and showing signs of faultering (doesn’t mean they going to crash just beware) and also like many, the Australian residential housing prices are in some trouble (once again not that they’ll crash but that there’s cause for concern). Now whilst, many commentators (including me) agree with these views, Charlie (like me) is of the belief that the Reserve bank is not likely to (or should not) increase interest rates in the short term and that there is a reasonable probability that interest rates could be lower in 12 months time, such is the weakness in the underlying Australian economy. If the Reserve Bank increases rates Charlie believes this could be potentially disastrous for the Australian housing market and we can all extrapolate on the potential effects of that.

It is amazing that economists of the bigger banks are suggesting rate hikes, particularly given they are more likely to suffer the consequences of a housing market decline. Either way, Charlie believes that the real sufferers of a housing market decline are likely to be companies in the consumer discretionary sector and as we’ve seen in recent days, some of the bigger players in property securities, like Westfield, Mirvac and Co.

As mentioned in earlier posts, Australian investors are facing some big risks…

  • very very high commodity prices (for when they crash they really crash)
  • record high residential property prices (that have effectively propped up this ecoomy through the GFC)
  • China needing to slow and contain inflation
  • a Euro Sovereign crisis that could always overflow into global financial markets
  • record high AUD that is contributing to our two speed economy and preventing foreign investment

Our markets are mostly financial services and commodities (plus a fair share of property) so when investing ensure these risks are considered in full.

May 06

Increase in Government Bond Yields Today

Contrary to suggestions in my last post, yields across the yield curve have moved a bit today…as the above chart shows the curve is up between 5bp and 9bps. This is a result of the Reserve Bank increasing its inflation outlook over the next 2 years. The Reserve Bank believes inflation will be above its target range due to increases in the costs of fruit and vegetables thanks to the Queensland floods as well as wage inflation caused from the mining sector. It also expects unemploymet to fall to 4.25%.

May 06

The extreme but possible storm ahead

Attended a Researcher’s conference yesterday which had an interesting line-up of speakers that covered China, the global economy, Small cap stocks, and . The first guy was very impressive, an investment Strategist, he did a “Me-style” global economic presentation (perhaps that’s why I liked him) where the key points were…

  1. Commodity Prices in a  bubble
  2. Australian house prices in a bubble
  3. China must/will slow, given inflationary pressures, and internal asset bubbles
  4. Australian dollar at irrationally high levels
  5. Euro Sovereign crisis must result in defaults for Greece, Portugal, Ireland,
  6. US economy is stuffed and recovery will be slow for many years

Whilst these are extreme views its not difficult to make a case for any of them. His markets forecast was that he was forecasting global shares to outperform Australian shares…fine. BUT, he then articulated that he was still quite confident in the Australian economy, Australian sharemarket and that our interest rates will rise (which is clearly a consensus view).

My comments…how on earth can anyone (and many do) agree on points 1,2,3, and 5 and not think our economy (and sharemarket) is facing a potential perfect storm (I actually put this question in these words to him)? To me unfortunately  his conflict of interest, as a fundie, got in the way of his answer. Either way, I’m also a little concerned about points 1 through to 3 (or even 5 given our reliance on the global banking system…point 6 is a factored in and its likely impact other than to keep the US dollar weak) and the downside risks to our economy and markets. If interest rates do go up, then that could be the catalyst to set off point 2 which could flow into the financial system and the rest of the Aussie economy and therefore sharemarkets. If China slows, as Nouriel Roubini is forecasting along with many others, then the biggest impact on our market will be the impact on point 1 (although aided by a cushioning effect from point 4 also dropping) which could be quite shocking (~35% of our market is Resource based).

I’ll end by quoting Jeremy Grantham from his latest newsletter, “beware the sell-side strategist offering arguments as to why overpriced markets are actually cheap”…whilst the analyst wasn’t necessarily saying assets were cheap he was denying the potential impact of these expensive markets on our own therefore suggesting our market is fairly priced…unfortunately given the downside risk I’m not so sure.

Plenty of food for thought.

May 03

Australian Government Bond Yield Curve

With last week’s high CPI figures coming out there has been increased talk about the Reserve Bank increasing interest rates. The above yield curve chart shows that since 12 April, the yields on government bonds have actually decreased across the board by around 20bps suggesting less long term confidence in our economy than two weeks ago. As has been commented on, the CPI figures were high largely (not totally) because of the high Food and Energy prices…keep in mind the Reserve Bank’s actions will have virtually zero impact on Food and Energy prices as they are high because of a combination of natural disasters, middle east conflict, and a bit of proprietary trading by those nasty US investment banks.

With home prices starting to fall (I did say that residential property would peak when my partner and I purchased a property back in February), the Australian dollar killing our tourism and foreign investment, and underlying inflation (excluding volatile items) actually near 10year lows, whilst our economy is still looking well, as the yield curve movement suggests our economy is not as rosy as the papers and fund managers make us believe and controllable inflation is under control.

Hopefully no interest rate rise today!

Apr 30

To Hedge or not to hedge?…MSCI provides an answer

Interesting paper by MSCI Research came out eaarlier in the week about hedging…click here. Its US centric with some interesting analysis and but the basic conclusion should apply to any country. i.e. basically over the long run currencies revert to the mean resulting in no real difference, but over the shorter term currency effects can have quite an impact. However, for this US study, hedging “generally reduces volatility most of the time for most currencies at all horizons”…BTW…this study was analysing equity returns (all global fixed interest should be hedged in aportfolio context assuming you are using it for income whereby currency effects add way to much volatility for a “defensive asset”).

Apr 30

Macroeconomic Rap – Keynes vs Kayek – Parts I and II

Just got onto these courtesy of Felix Salmon. Both of these are so clever with outstanding production. I’v never learnt so much or gained so much clarity about macroeconomics in such a short time…and they’re rap songs! My favourite is probably Round Two but the first is still a must.

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0nERTFo-Sk]

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GTQnarzmTOc]

Brilliant!

Apr 14

A lack of Global Small Cap investing???

International equity small-cap stocks widely outperformed large-cap stocks over the year to September 2010, returning 24.4 per cent and 12.7 per cent, respectively in US dollar terms.

I took the above from today’s InvestorDaily email and whilst the fact that global small cap outperformed large cap is not surprising, as it is bound to happen from time to time, what is surprising is the complete lack of selection of global small cap fund that advisers and investors have. I noticed at my place of work we have very few on our approved product list so I looked up Lonsec to see what other funds they may have at least “Recommended” and there were only three!…BlackRock, Zurich, and Schroder.

The Fama and French three factor model has been around for almost twenty years, many of us have read Jeremy Siegel’s book, “Stocks for the Long Run”, and there are many local and international papers which have similar messages…that is…over time small cap stocks outperform large cap stocks on a risk-adjusted basis. Of course, the past doesn’t equal the future, but we are creatures of habit most of the time and our market has shown little appetite for small cap…bizarre.

One of the recent posts I put up referred to S&P’s SPIVA report which also showed that active managers have recently been more successful in small cap stock selection than large cap and this makes intuitive sense. There are fewer analysts covering small cap space so there are more opportunities for mis-pricings so we can make a simplistic conclusion that the small cap part of the market is less efficient than large cap. OK…so small caps are the go…but there’s usually a but…small cap stocks are much more volatile and I must admit it is this volatility that is often the turn off (perhaps the additional illiquidity is too)…so there is a reasonable fear factor associated with them and I can understand that.

What I don’t understand is this insistence on regional biases…particularly Asia. Personally I don’t understand why you would constrain your investment universe (and opportunity) simply based on region. Why not place your funds with a global small cap or global unconstrained manager (with proven skill and aligned bias) and let them make the bet as to whether Asia is worthy of an overweight. By investing in an Asian managed fund we are really choosing a Global Small Cap fund anyway, so my simple message is go global and don’t reduce your investment opportunity.

Please note…despite these comments I have no views as to whether global small cap investments are likely to outperform or perform well moving forward.

Mar 31

A Look at Bond Risks & the GFC

I’ve just uploaded a neat little article (if I do say so myself) on the various risks of bonds and what happeneded during the GFC. Its more of an education piece and if you’re interested in a read please click here.

Mar 22

The Best Australian Share Funds don’t achieve their Alpha Targets

Source: van Eyk, Morningstar

The above chart contains some performance statistics of a list of Australian share funds with at least a 5 year track record and were awarded an A-Rating by van Eyk this month. The A-rating is the second highest possible rating van Eyk award with the highest being AA…no Australian share fund achieved an AA rating in this latest review so this table is effectively the highest rated Australian share funds. I must point out that Integrity, Solaris, and Sigma have funds that were also A-Rated but they do not make the table due to a short performance history.

Before I provide any analysis I’ll provide some background to this simple table. The performance was measured over 5 years using monthly figures. So if a fund only had a 5 year track record, then the “total number of 5 year periods” is 1. If a fund has a 6 year track record, then the “total number of 5 year periods” is 13 because we have 13 separate rolling 5 year numbers due to monthly data. The table shows the number of 5 year periods where the fund outperforms the ASX200 as well as its stated alpha target.

Unfortunately, of these 9 highly rated funds, only 2 funds, Fidelity and Ausbil Dexia, have exceeded their alpha target more than 50% of the time. Fidelity’s Australian share fund has exceeded their alpha target (2.5%) every single rolling five year period since their inception which is absolutely outstanding and an absolute credit to this team. Fidelity started around the start of the new bull phase in 2003 and have obviously had to endure the GFC as well as its choppy recovery.

Ausbil, whose performance figures started around mid-1997 also have outstanding results. Whilst 60% of the time they have exceeded their alpha target they have exceeded the ASX200 index 100% of the time when looking at their 5 year rolling average.

Whilst Alphinity (formerly Challenger) has shown near decent numbers (49%) in terms of achieving their alpha target, I don’t group Alphinity in the same league as Fidelity and Ausbil because most of their strong performance occurred during the 1990s when they were possibly the best Australian share manager around and their performance since 2003 has been nothing short of abysmal…unfortunately this is a fund whose performance track record has effectively died in recent years.

As for the rest, it looks like considering their alpha target in terms of performance expectation is a complete waste of time. Most are nowhere near achieving this target and several managers haven’t achieved one single rolling period in excess of their target. I wonder how the fund managers feel continually failing to achieve their target…must be depressing. 

Anyway, at least all nine managers have outperformed their index, over 5 year periods, more than half of the time…well, at least before platforms fees, retail fees, adviser fees, etc!

Mar 21

One Week Later – ASX200 generally unaffected by Japanese Tragedy

Source: Bloomberg

The above chart shows the movement in the ASX200 over last week. It closed before the Japanese earthquake on Friday 11th March on basically the same level ot closed on Friday 18th. Given the market is slightly up today (0.35% at the time of writing) means that since the earthquake the Australian market is actually up! Japan is only our second biggest trading partner, buys a lot of Australian stuff, has sold all of our bonds so that it can pay for its rescue, but our market is up!

I’m sure there’s something I’ve missed, but I find this short term macro-result for our market baffling.

Older posts «

» Newer posts