Dec 16

Global House Price Comparison

Found the above chart at The Big Picture .

Unfortunately Australian Real House Prices are missing but I did a quick calculation using ABS data. From the start of 1997 to the start of 2008, inflation adjusted house prices in Australia increased from a base score of 100 to 212 which places Australia somewhere between Spain and the UK in the above chart. Since 2008 Ireland and Spain’s property prices have fallen significantly whilst, off the top of my head, UK hasn’t fallen so much. However Australian house prices, using my calculations, have increased such that our index score sits around 230.

As a result I’m pretty confident that since 1997 our housing market has experienced the highest real return of the above nations. Jeremy Grantham, of GMO, believes UK and Australian residential property markets are both in bubble territory (or at least very very expensive). Whether you believe that or not, the Australian housing market is certainly one of the key risks to our ongoing economic strength as a nation. Whilst there are numerous reasons provided for why Australia didn’t suffer during the GFC to the same extent as others (regulation, banking strength, etc), I’m sure the strength in our housing market was an essential factor.

Dec 16

Fee for service responsible for increased passive investment???

A change in adviser remuneration structure is causing a structural shift in asset allocation away from active products towards more passive products such as exchange traded funds (ETFs) and passive funds, according to Fidelity Investment Managers.

The above paragraph, taken from Money Management’s daily,  isn’t quite true. Whilst I believe adviser remuneration restructure has some impact on the move towards passive products, the big move to passive management really accelerated after investors and advisers saw that many active managers (including hedge funds) didn’t quite deliver their marketing hype during the negative return periods of the GFC. These large negative market returns frightened investors who demanded increased transparency, simplicity, and definitely at a reasonable cost…passively managed strategies tick all of these boxes and whilst some Morningstar and Mercer performance tables show a comeback of the active manager the damage was done and the psychology has changed from chasing return to reducing risk. 

I have a belief that, in general, investors and advisers felt their payments for alpha (active) risk would somehow reduce a portfolio’s beta (market) risk…alpha and beta risks are independent or uncorrelated so if the market goes down a lot then every long only fund goes down a lot…the impact of active management for the long only portfolio has a relatively small impact in big market downturns. So advisers and investors have simply decided to de-risk their portfolio by removing their portfolio’s only reducible risk…the alpha risk….and they just happen to save fees at the same time which is always an easier sell for an adviser. In fact, the reality is that the retail investor not only reduced their exposure to alpha risk but also beta risk as the proportion of cash or term deposits held by investors has possibly never been higher.

The GFC has changed the way everyone looks at risk and we are all a little more conservative and wary today.

Dec 15

S&P500 Appears Overvalued

The Shiller PE ratio has been a pretty useful guide over the years as to whether the US sharemarket in general is over or undervalued. The above chart shows this statistic to the end of November  where it has the value of 21.8. Compared to its historic average (16.4) the S&P500 is around 33% overvalued and compared to the 40 year average (19.2) is around 14% overvalued. There could be many arguments supporting the current price, such as the Fed’s quantitative easing part 2 (QE2)channelling significant cash into the market and the continuation of record low interest rates, weak US Dollar inviting foreign capital, etc., but that does not provide sufficient reason to suggest the S&P500 is good value.

The US economy will not be bouncing towards massive growth, it will be a slow and painful journey; the reason why QE2 exists is that deflation is the threat, not inflation as the consumer is struggling, the US Housing market and unemployment levels are not going to improve dramatically for quite some time. So buying a market with a high PE with the high potential of slow growth is fraught with danger.

Hopefully I’m wrong as many superannuation funds depend on a strong US sharemarket but personally I’m underweight this part of the global sharemarket as the downside risks appear high.

Dec 10

The RBA’s New Chart Pack

The Reserve Bank of Australia have updated their website so that charts on global and local economic statistics or investment markets are far more accessible. It is a wonderful resource that many use …check it out here.

Dec 01

So much for the bailout…

Source: Bloomberg

If you can’t pay your debts then you can’t pay your debts…additional credit doesn’t quite cut it. Clearly the market is unconvinced by the bailout package for the Irish and bond yields continue their upward climb. One of the desired outcomes of a bailout package is the hope it will calm markets…it clearly failed there.

Meanwhile in a different part of Europe, Italy, which appears to have the ability to pay its debts thanks to a low-ish budget deficit, has a very scary looking increase in their 10 year bond yields. I could also show similar looking charts for numerous other European countries (Hungary, Belgium,..)  but I’m sure you get the picture…so to speak.

These Euro Sovereign debt problems are getting contagious.

Nov 30

My Least Favourite Hedge Funds

I’m always being approached by fund managers pitching their latest or greatest fund and many of them appear quite good with impressive people, performance, and/or process. Every now and then I see a fund that to me makes little sense and the latest to annoy me is the generic Asian Fund of Hedge Fund…I haven’t named the actual manager as there is quite a few managers doing them.

My reason behind my dislike goes like this…these funds are selling two attributes…1) they are focused on Asia and it’s expected strong economic growth which is expected to generate strong returns, and 2) the absolute return focus of the underlying funds and therefore their combination. I view the combination of these attributes as a little contradictory.

If I want an absolute return focused fund of hedge fund, I do not want to restrict my selection to one region. If there is a skillful manager based or investing in Ireland or Greece or US with a successful absolute return focus why should my fund ignore that potential?

Having a geographic focus is a beta (market) play whilst hedge funds are an alpha (skill) play…they shouldn’t be used to confuse or for marketing purposes just because naive investors will fall for it. If you are a fund of hedge fund keep it local for tax reasons or go global to increase your opportunity set. If you want to invest in a region, you are typically wanting to do so because you believe markets are going to go up… so do yourself a favour and buy a cheap index fund or long only managed fund that is region focused and save yourself some fees and increased risk.

Combining the two actually increases your risks of not achieving your desired outcome which can be achieved more efficiently with a global fund of hedge fund and a long only Asian fund combined to provide an acceptable level of risk.

Nov 24

Spain is the latest focus

Source: Bloomberg

The above chart shows 10 year Spanish bond yields hitting record highs overnight…this intense acceleration of yields (or sell-off) is a pretty strong sign this Euro-Sovereign crisis is a long long way from over. Expect more volatility in sharemarkets yet as Spain carries more risk to Europe and the Global Economy than Ireland does given it comprises around 13% of European GDP…its unemployment is still around 20% and Spanish bank’s balance sheets must be under a fair bit of pressure so hang on for the upcoming ride of economic fear in markets and newspapers.

Nov 17

Australian Government Bond Yield Curve – Nov 2010

Not surprisingly since August 31 interest rates have increased across the board on the back of stronger local economic data (good unemployment, strong China etc) and now the yield curve has rates above those back at the end of May 2010.

It will be interesting to see what happend to interest rates over the coming days/weeks given the latest round of Euro-Sovereign crisis issues have started impacting the risk trade. My guess is that equities markets will be taking a break for a little while and there will be movement back to cash and bonds which should see the yield curve flatten a touch.

It certainly is a very tough investment environment at the moment…shares are loaded with all sorts of risk from the current Euro Sovereign crisis, to the sluggish global economy, to the potential over-reliance on China to perform. Bond prices are high (or yields are low) and property markets still appear fragile. As for commodities…there are good arguments for downside just as much as the upside story so a high risk story with limited expected return. If we’re looking for some decent returns I guess its time to get a little creative as the market (whatever market that may be) has a low return expectation accompanied by some higher than usual risk.

Nov 16

Government Initiated Inflation

For the first time in a while I decided to have a detailed look at what has been driving the inflaiton results in Australia…and whilst our 2.8% inflation figure is near the top end of the RBA’s range, it is only at the top end because of government…not consumer demand as we are often led to believe. The main inflation drivers are…

  • Alcohol and Tobacco…surely due to increaed government taxes (or excise or whatever the appropriate term) and I’m sure the government doesn’t mind these inflated prices given the associated health costs…11.2% increase over 12 months
  • Education…most education is controlled by government …5.8% increase over 12 months
  • Housing…this obviously includes rents, and mortgage costs…putting up interest costs obviously has the reverse effect on this CPI input to other costs but the other housing cost that contributes is Rates…which is determined by your friendly local council….5.2% increase over 12 months
  • Health…lots to this but I’m sure the 8% increase in private health insurance premiums the government allows each year results in an 8% hike in related health care costs!…anyway…5.2% increase over 12 months

Our other core basic needs such as food, clothing, transport, communication, recreation, and household contents and services as a whole showed virtually no inflation whatsoever.

So whilst these other costs may be due for a price rise on the back of a stronger economy (sort of stronger…its really only a strong commodities related economy), if we’re really worried about inflation perhaps the government can remove some of their assistance in specific areas.

Personally I’m not worried about inflation at all…I’m more worried about the continued sick global economy and wondering what the next shock will be (Ireland banking system and its European relationship don’t appear to have much impact on us thus far??)

Nov 11

Increasingly looking bad for PIGS

Source: Bloomberg…from left to right…Ireland, Portugal, Greece, and Spain on the second row

I found the above charts from Calculated Risk and these sharply increasing yields for each of their bonds is suggesting that the Euro-Sovereign crisis is far from over. I can only imagine there will be significant pressure on the solvency of each of these countries banking systems and may result in bank runs such that the money ends up under the mattress here and there.

Older posts «

» Newer posts