Jul 28

European trouble again?

Italy – Germany 10 Year Bond Spread

Source: Bloomberg

The above chart shows the spread between Italian 10 year bonds and German 10 year bonds. I found it via Paul Krugman’s blog.

As Krugman suggests it looks like things are starting to look pretty grim again in Euro land as the spreads are heading towards those “pre-Greek debt deal” levels. Throw in the US debt debacle and it looks like the rough time in equity markets will continue.

So what to do? Short term, it looks like Australian bonds or cash are best…bonds are certainly expensive with yields very low (yields are below RBA cash rates out to 7 years maturity) but that’s probably not surprising as I’m sure the financial strength of the Australian government has put them in great demand given troubles in the other developed nations of the world.

Despite this suggestion, equities are priced relatively low but so they should be given the risks.

Jul 28

Inflation Up? Not really just interest rate rise panic

The above chart has been copied from www.rba.gov.au and  shows annual CPI change over the last 16 quarters and guess what? The latest quarter’s figure, excluding volatile items is 2.5%! Right in the middle of the RBA’s inflation target of 2% to 3%.

When the Reserve Bank looks at inflation they do not, or should not, consider volatile items such as food and energy. Why? because these items go up and down in price thanks to global markets, weather events, Middle East tensions, and the Reserve Bank’s actions will have little impact on their price. Certainly, after the weather events we have seen locally at the start of the year, food prices (which are a large part of anyone’s budget) have increased and next season prices are bound to revert to normal.

Because of these “cost-push” issues (tha also include health insurers increasing premiums, high petrol prices, etc) we all have less to pay for the more discretionary items and that is why retailers are struggling (NOT because of internet purchasing alone) and why the true core inflation is actually under control at 2.5%. “Demand-pull” inflation does not appear to be an issue and when you throw in the potentially catastrophic global financial issues in Euro and USA (neither of which are anywhere near fully resolved), I don’t believe the Reserve Bank will or should increase interest rates for some time yet….and the market agrees…why? interest rates are quite low…see below chart.

Australian Government Bond Yields – 28 July 2011

Source: Bloomberg

Jul 25

A Few Retirement Income Articles

I haven’t written too much on retirement income recently, well just a little bit. Anyway, before I write a whole lot more (my day job is currently focused on this area) I thought I’d post a couple of my older retirement income articles for those that may be interested…also can’t help but notice that Jeremy Cooper is writing a lot about what I wrote about a while ago. My articles are…

I think I’m overdue for a piece on Variable Annuities  which is coming soon…variable annuities are a great concept but a little too expensive in this country. Stay tuned.

Jul 16

Australian Government Bond Yield…the outlook’s not so good any more

What a difference three months can make. The Australian Government Bond Yield has gone from a positive outlook, to negative, and Bill Evans of Westpac has just made the call that the next interest rate move from the Reserve Bank should be down. For those of us who read this blog, you  may recall that Charlie Lanchester of Perpetual actually told me that he believed interest rates would be going down before they go up as he believed our economy was so much weaker than many believed (Blog entry here)…in fact most of our concerns have actually played out to some degree. Anyway, I digress.

A couple of nights ago, I dialled into a Blackrock teleconference that I think was run from their head office overseas, where they conducted a panel discussion of the Euro Sovereign Crisis and what they thought the future held. Bottom line was that they were very positive for the outlook of both European and Global equities as they believed valuations are discounted enough to provide some downside cushion and if the pending defaults from the Euro Sovereign Crisis is handled in an orderly fashion then markets should perform well in this second half of the year. Of course, if it was disorderly and contagion starts to appear then all bets are off and no-one really knows what the outcome would be.

Personally, my big concern is that contagion is quite a likely scenario adn I agree that the market adn economic impacts are unknown. Whilst I agree equities are well priced (compared to long-term history) and corporate balance sheets look strong, I’m making the call that it is absolutely prudent to be quite underweight equities as the risks appear enormous and I don’t want to be exposed to that contagion possibility. Even if corporates are looking strong, if the global financial system is stuffed because banks start becoming insolvent, through bank runs or asset value decline, then corporates may still be stuffed as spending grinds towards a halt like three years ago.

So where should we invest the sold down positions…I’m still backing Australian term deposits. The premium over bank bills is still attractive and it should continue as local banks continue to use term deposits as an important funding vehicle whilst overseas funding continues to be difficult. The Australian government debt position is very strong and our local banking scene will be fine.

Jul 05

Lifetime Annuities…only attractive if you live to 100!

A few weeks ago I mentioned that if you survive long enough, lifetime annuities are likely to offer the best return you could possibly get, thanks to the power of mortality credits. There are only two fixed annuity providers in the industry and I decided to analyse the rates of one of them. My analysis is pretty simple and doesn’t measure the fair value of the lifetime annuity with respect to current fixed interest yields but compares the lifetime annuity to a fixed term annuity to determine what one’s lifetime needs to be in order to break even.

Anyway, the table below shows that in order to justify purchasing a non-commutable lifetime annuity instead of a term certain annuity means that you need to live around 7 to 8 years longer than the average life expectancy of someone of the same gender and age! Good luck with that…lifetime annuities are not looking to be particularly good value at this point in time from this particularly provider…who is Challenger by the way…I can’t comment on Comminsure as I haven’t seen the rates (which are usually below Challenger’s!)

Tough gig if you have to live well into your nineties just to break even compared to a term certain annuity. The killer, so to speak, for lifetime annuities is that if you die beforehand the annuity finishes and payments stop, however for the term certain annuity at least the payments continue until the end of term.

Table 1 – Comparing Lifetime Annuity Prices to Term Certain Inflation Linked Annuities (Prices as 4 July 2011)

 

Jun 30

ING sells Australian funds management business to UBS

Looks like there’ll be a fair few redemptions coming up for ING’s and maybe even UBS’s managed funds because today ING have sold their Australian funds business to UBS. This is no comment on the quality of either team, but there is bound to be some unrest over the coming months as teams are merged and synergies are found.

The common belief is that when key people leave so too does performance, but even if performance doesn’t suffer, there will be some change in the style of the investmetn management…so…the investment exhibits different behaviour and the fees you pay as an investor are now paying for something most likely a little different.

I’m guessing the Research Houses will most likely be issuing HOLD ratings across many funds and this will be the catalyst for the redemptions as adviser’s recommend funds are switched to a more stable team…ditto for insto funds.

Jun 24

Australian Government Bond Yields…pretty much flat

Well, flat, it pretty much is. What a difference a couple of months can make…from a nice gentle normal looking yield curve to very very flat out to five years to maturity. Pretty obvious stuff here…housing has slowed, inflation isn’t a perceived threat, the Euro crisis has global recession potential written on it, and the US continues to be a near basket case. We re lucky we are a resources rich country for if that wasn’t the case this yield curve would be looking decidedly negative. Our two-speed economy has effectively levelled the yield curve out ad its an each way bet as to whether our economic growth will move above trend or continue its ‘at trend’ way.

Markets are a very tough pick right now. Volatility should continue to be the trend in equities (so if the VIX drops its bound to be a decent buy) and interest rates are likely to be fairly stagnant so a tough sell (although term deposits continue to be quite good given their continued premium over bonds). Australian property trusts appear correlated to both the weak Australian residential market and volatile equity market, and global property has run up so fast that its difficult to see further price growth. Aside from the volatility play I continue to think purchasing Chinese Yuan may be attractive over the long-term and it may be worth looking for some decent global macro hedge funds…I’d certainly want to diversify across them as if they get the next movement wrong then it could always be “ouch”.

Jun 12

Managing Inflation Risk…advisers have it wrong

Source: van Eyk Research

The above poll was taken by van Eyk Research on their subscription website. In terms of the sample, it is large (848 responses) so may be statistically representative of van Eyk subscribers whom I can only assume is financial advisers, researchers, and maybe fund managers. As shown almost 1 in 2 respondents believe equities offers the best protection against inflation, but unfortunately empirical analysis (that I and a few others have performed) show that equities definitely does not offer the “greatest protection against inflation risk”.

Over the last 140 years, there are two major periods of time where inflation was particularly high in the US…

  • During WWI, 1914-1919, where CPI averaged 13.3%pa, and
  • 1971-1981, where there was significant monetary expansion and high energy prices (including the oil shock of 1973-74) and CPI averaged 8.3%pa

As you would expect, inflation is a disaster for traditional bonds (government) and their returns over these two periods were a disastrous 2.1% and 3.8%, respectively. We all know that when inflation increases, so too does bond yields, hence prices decrease.

Unfortunately for (potentially) almost 50% of advisers, equity returns of the S&P500 only returned 11.6% and 5.8% respectively…failing to keep up with inflation whatsoever. So much for a decent hedge.

The asset classes that performed best were…

  • Housing…17.5%pa and 12.1%pa (National Association of Realtors)
  • Farmland…14.7% and 14.6%pa (NCREIF Farmland Index)
  • Gold…no data for WWI and 28%pa during 1971-81 (Spot Gold Price)
  • Silver…15.5%pa and 21.5%pa (Spot Silver Price)

and, given inflation linked bonds would have paid a premium to inflation, obviously they also would have outperformed inflation unlike equities!

Floating Rate Securities were a mixed bag over these two periods, whereby the Ibbootson Commercial Paper index, provided returns of 4.7% during WWI (clearly underperforming both CPI and Equities) but provided a solid 8.8%pa during 1971-81, outperforming both CPI and Equities.

So, it looks like adviser have fallen for the good old marketing campaign that the Australian Financial Services industry has pedaled for a long time, that equities solves all. Unfortunately I believe the results above are a reflection of the fact that Australian advisers have very little selection for their clients in terms of commodities and inflation linked bonds hence the equity bias.

So when do equities perform best…when there is disinflation/moderate inflation or when there is price stability. Deflation, is also disastrous for equities. Given the debate around whether the US will enter high inflation or deflation it sort of makes sense why equities have gone nowhere.

Reference: Darst, David (2008), The Art of Asset Allocation, McGraw Hill

 

Jun 09

European Bond Yields

I found this table on Calculated Risk and liked it so much I had to have my own…as I’m sicking of looking up other websites to find the latest Euro yields.

[table id=1 /]

 

Jun 07

Reserve Bank No Change…but some movement on the yield curve

Source: Bloomberg

As the above Australian Government Bond Yield curve chart shows, whilst the Reserve Bank left the cash rate unchanged, the shorter end of the yield curve decreased in yield by up to 5bps. This represented around a 1% increase in price of the Australian government bonds maturing within the next 5 years…quite a significant daily move. Bottom line…the Reserve Bank have effectively admitted that the Australian economy is a little softer than previous thought and the market has taken that on board and reduced the likelihood of another rate rise by buying up more bonds.

Older posts «

» Newer posts